VLC turned down $30+ million dollars to keep VLC ad-free | Lex Fridman Podcast
Jean-Baptiste Kempf, the steward of VLC media player, explains how VLC evolved from a student networking project at École Centrale Paris in the 1990s into one of the world's most widely used media players. He describes repeatedly turning down tens of millions of dollars from shady advertising companies to keep VLC free, open source, and ad-free. His motivation was rooted in ethics, personal integrity, and a sense of responsibility to the broader community of contributors.
Summary
The interview begins with Lex Fridman referencing the well-known Reddit meme about Jean-Baptiste Kempf (JB) turning down millions of dollars to keep VLC free. JB confirms the story, acknowledging he refused dozens of millions of dollars on multiple occasions, stating he did so because it was not moral and not the right thing to do.
JB then traces the unlikely origins of VLC back to the École Centrale Paris, an elite French engineering school whose campus was uniquely managed entirely by its students due to being owned by an alumni non-profit rather than the university itself. In the 1980s, IBM and 3Com sponsored a token ring network experiment on campus. By the mid-1990s, the slow token ring network became a problem as students wanted to play latency-sensitive games like Doom and Duke Nukem. Seeking a faster network, students approached the university and corporate partners, eventually connecting with the CIO of Bull, a French company, who suggested streaming satellite television over a fast campus network instead of installing individual dishes and decoders for each of the 1,500 students.
This led to the 'Network 2000' project, a rough but functional demo that crashed after 45 seconds and leaked memory — but the demo only needed to run for 40 seconds. The project used MPEG-2 video streamed over a newly built ATM network running at 155 Mbps, one of the fastest in Europe at the time. Though the project was considered complete, two students later revived the idea into the broader VideoLAN project, which took about three years to convince the university to release as open source due to concerns about IP and monetizing the MPEG-2 decoder.
JB joined the project in 2003, when he enrolled at the university, and subsequently created the VideoLAN non-profit organization to extract the project from the university and make it sustainable. He emphasizes that he did not create VLC — it emerged organically from the VideoLAN project — but he credits himself with keeping it alive during a near-death moment around 2005 when only two active developers remained. Under his stewardship, VLC grew from hundreds of thousands of users to what he estimates are billions of installations worldwide.
On the topic of the financial offers, JB explains that the deals presented to him were predominantly from shady advertising companies wanting to bundle spyware toolbars, change browser or search engine settings, or place ads inside VLC. He draws a distinction: he is not anti-money and has founded startups, but he believes money must be earned ethically. He notes that had a legitimate company like Netflix approached him about integration, the outcome might have been different. He also argues that accepting such deals would have killed the project within three years through community forking and loss of trust. The last offer he received was described as 'obscene,' and came with the rationalization that the money could fund new open source projects — a pitch he still rejected. His final reasoning was simple: he needs to be able to go to sleep at night feeling good about his decisions.
Key Insights
- JB argues that accepting the advertising deals — not just for ethical reasons but practical ones — would have killed VLC within three years, as the community would have forked the project and moved on, making the financial gain self-defeating.
- JB clarifies that he did not create VLC; it emerged organically from the VideoLAN student project, which itself grew out of the Network 2000 experiment, and he feels this lineage means he was not fully 'legitimate' to monetize it unilaterally.
- JB describes how VLC nearly died around 2005 when only two active developers remained, and that his personal decision to dedicate his life to the project is what allowed it to grow from hundreds of thousands to billions of users.
- The origins of VLC trace back to a 1994–1995 student effort to upgrade a token ring campus network so they could play Doom and Duke Nukem, which accidentally led to building one of Europe's fastest networks and pioneering local video streaming a decade before YouTube.
- JB recounts that the final and largest offer he rejected came with the persuasive rationalization that the money could be used to fund new open source projects — a 'mind trick' he found difficult but ultimately dismissed because the method of obtaining the money was still wrong.
Topics
Transcript
[0:02] So, as the legend goes, JB, you uh repeatedly turned down millions of dollars to uh keep VLC open source, free for everyone, without ads. So, take me through the reasoning behind that decision of leaving millions of dollars on the table. Yeah, that's like almost a meme, right? On on Reddit. >> There literally is a meme on Reddit. 9GAG and yeah, yeah, I See, there's you >> [laughter] [0:33] >> looking like a wizard in the in the VLC hat on Reddit. This is JB, the creator of VLC media player. He refused tens of millions of dollars in order to keep VLC as free Thanks, Jean-Baptiste Kempf. You can even summon him on Reddit. Yeah, and…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Lex Clips
Sex in the Roman Empire | Anthony Kaldellis and Lex Fridman
Anthony Kaldellis discusses Justinian I's reign, focusing on his meritocratic appointment of talented individuals regardless of social class (including his wife Theodora, a former sex worker), his monumental codification of Roman law through the Corpus Juris Civilis, and the paradox of his harsh stance on sexuality despite his own unconventional personal choices.
Did the plague kill half the Roman Empire? | Anthony Kaldellis and Lex Fridman
Anthony Kaldellis discusses the Plague of Justinian (541 AD), arguing against the maximalist claim that it killed 50% of the Roman population. He contends that modern pathogen identification combined with historical evidence shows the plague had far less impact than commonly assumed, as evidenced by Justinian's continued military campaigns and taxation during the outbreak.
Persian Empire vs Roman Empire: The war that destroyed both empires | Anthony Kaldellis
Anthony Kaldellis discusses the Byzantine-Persian War (602-628 CE) and its catastrophic consequences for both empires, explaining how Heraclius's civil war weakened Roman defenses, the eventual Arab conquests stripped away the empire's richest provinces, and the subsequent Byzantine survival through military innovation like Greek fire and strategic defensive reorganization.
Why the Roman Empire collapsed in the East | Anthony Kaldellis and Lex Fridman
Anthony Kaldellis discusses how the Eastern Roman Empire, despite territorial losses, maintained remarkable internal stability and could have lasted another thousand years without external invasions. He attributes this resilience to two factors: authorities convincingly persuading subjects they ruled on their behalf, and a unified Roman and Orthodox identity that made the alternatives to imperial rule seem worse.
Lessons from the Roman Empire for modern-day - historian explains | Anthony Kaldellis
Historian Anthony Kaldellis discusses lessons from the 2,200-year Roman Empire for modern America, focusing on the importance of building lasting institutions that serve the majority, aligning foreign policy rhetoric with actual military actions, and the persistent elements of human nature across centuries.