DiscussionTechnical

The breakdown of physics: Does a singularity reveal that we need new physics | Lex Fridman

Lex Clips

The discussion explores how mathematical singularities and equation breakdowns signal the need for new physics, using examples from general relativity and fluid dynamics. While Navier-Stokes equations are exceptionally useful engineering tools, their fundamental properties—like whether solutions blow up in finite time—remain unsolved, potentially revealing deeper physical principles similar to how Einstein's theory superseded Newtonian physics.

Summary

Lex Fridman and his guest discuss Feynman's observation that we can write down general equations like Maxwell's equations and Schrödinger's equation, but cannot deduce from the equations alone what phenomena are actually possible without simulation and testing. The conversation centers on what happens when equations break down or exhibit singularities.

They examine two contrasting cases: Einstein's general relativity, where Schwarzschild's solution revealed a 'blowup' that initially seemed like an error but turned out to perfectly describe black holes; and the Navier-Stokes equations governing fluid dynamics. Unlike general relativity's singularities, Navier-Stokes breakdowns occur because the continuum fluid model becomes invalid at molecular scales—other physics takes over.

The guest emphasizes that Navier-Stokes equations are among the most studied and applied equations in engineering worldwide, yet fundamental mathematical questions remain unanswered: Do solutions blow up in finite time? What other solutions exist? These aren't merely academic questions but represent a gap in understanding what the equations actually permit. The discussion suggests that where equations break down often signals opportunities for discovering new physics or phenomena, though the breakthrough isn't guaranteed.

They also explore whether understanding exotic solutions could enable better flow control—a major engineering challenge—pointing to how nature (birds, insects) manipulates vortices in ways humans currently cannot replicate. The conversation concludes with a reflection on Feynman's earlier observation that technological solutions to problems differ radically from nature's solutions, exemplified by planes that don't flap like birds.

Key Insights

  • We can write down very general equations like Maxwell's equations or Schrödinger's equations, but currently cannot deduce from the equation alone what phenomena are possible without simulation and testing—we cannot tell 'what's inside' the equation.
  • Schwarzschild's solution revealed what appeared to be a blowup in Einstein's general relativity equations, initially thought to be an error, but turned out to perfectly predict black holes, showing that singularities can reveal genuine physics rather than mathematical failures.
  • Navier-Stokes equations break down not because the physics is wrong, but because at small enough scales you reach individual molecules and atomic structures that no longer follow the continuous fluid model—different physics takes over.
  • The Navier-Stokes equation is one of the most studied and used equations in the entire engineering world across every industry, yet we don't know this fundamental property: whether solutions blow up in finite time or not.
  • Where equations break down and singularities appear is often a window or door to discovering new physics, with high statistical likelihood—exemplified by how Newtonian physics breaking down led to Einstein's theories.

Topics

Mathematical singularities as indicators of new physicsLimitations of differential equations in predicting phenomenaNavier-Stokes equation and unsolved mathematical problemsGeneral relativity and black holes as example of equations predicting realityScale-dependent validity of physical modelsFlow control and engineering applicationsDifferences between technological and natural solutions

Transcript

[0:02] But, there's this really nice Feynman quote that, you know, we know how to write down these very general equations, Maxwell's equations, Navier-Stokes equations, Schrödinger's equations, but we currently don't know from the equation what phenomena is possible. You know, if you'd never visited Earth, could you have possibly predicted the sunsets and the tides and all the phenomena just from like a partial differential equation? Like, we're not even close to there. And there's some very fundamental math questions about, you know, if I can-- I can write [0:33] down a differential equation. I can't tell you what's inside of it. We still have to simulate, we still have to test, we still have to do this very…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Lex Clips

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.