Do antipsychotic drugs work? | Andrew Scull and Lex Fridman
Andrew Scull discusses the efficacy and serious side effects of antipsychotic drugs, explaining that while they help some patients, many are non-responders, and the medications carry substantial risks including tardive dyskinesia, weight gain, metabolic syndrome, and cognitive dulling. The landmark CATIE study revealed that newer, expensive second-generation antipsychotics are no more effective than older first-generation drugs, with 67-82% of patients dropping out due to inefficacy or intolerable side effects.
Summary
Andrew Scull, a medical historian, discusses the complex reality of antipsychotic medication efficacy and safety with Lex Fridman. He begins by establishing that antipsychotics work for some patients but not others, similar to how antidepressants fail for many people with depression. Scull then details the serious side effects that were initially downplayed or ignored by the psychiatric profession, including akathisia (constant restlessness and motion), Parkinsonian symptoms, and tardive dyskinesia—late-onset involuntary jerky movements primarily affecting facial muscles and tongue, which can create a stigmatizing appearance.
Scull explains that tardive dyskinesia was largely ignored for approximately 20 years until psychiatrist George Crane published a landmark paper in Science (around the 1960s) highlighting the profession's failure to address this iatrogenic harm. By the 1980s, the American Psychiatric Association and drug companies became concerned. Clozapine, developed in 1957 but initially rejected for the American market due to its tendency to destroy white blood cells (causing patient deaths), was revisited as a potential solution to the tardive dyskinesia problem. It was successfully reintroduced in the late 1980s, but required weekly blood checks as a safety measure. This led to the development of a new class of "second-generation antipsychotics" including Risperdal and Zyprexa.
Scull critically addresses the drug approval and research process, explaining that pharmaceutical companies funded studies, controlled data, and only released favorable results. For FDA approval, companies only needed two successful trials out of potentially 15 conducted—a practice he finds problematic. The pivotal 2005 CATIE study, funded by the National Institute of Mental Health (not industry), compared a cheap first-generation antipsychotic with four newer, expensive second-generation drugs. The findings were striking: the new drugs were not more efficacious than the old drug, and 67-82% of patients dropped out due to drug inefficacy or unbearable side effects.
Regarding side effects of second-generation drugs, Scull describes a new profile: while tardive dyskinesia decreased somewhat, patients experienced significant weight gain (10-50+ pounds), leading to metabolic syndrome, diabetes, and heart disease. He emphasizes that all medications involve cost-benefit analysis—the relief from psychiatric symptoms must be weighed against new dangers that may or may not materialize. Critically, there are currently no biological markers to predict which patients will respond well, which will experience severe side effects, or which will suffer cognitive/personality changes. Scull notes that some patients drop out specifically because they experience a loss of mental richness and personality, preferring to tolerate hallucinations rather than the emotional flattening caused by medication.
Key Insights
- Scull argues that tardive dyskinesia was deliberately ignored by the psychiatric profession for approximately 20 years before George Crane's 1960s Science publication exposed the problem, demonstrating institutional negligence regarding drug-induced harm.
- The CATIE study (2005) demonstrated that newer, patent-protected second-generation antipsychotics costing 10 times more than older first-generation drugs were not more efficacious, contradicting the justification for their expense and widespread adoption.
- Between 67-82% of patients in the CATIE trial discontinued their antipsychotic medication because either the drug was ineffective or they could not tolerate the side effects, indicating fundamental limitations in current antipsychotic treatment options.
- Scull explains that pharmaceutical companies controlled research data and only released favorable results, requiring only two successful trials out of potentially 15 for FDA approval—a practice that obscures true drug safety and efficacy profiles.
- Some patients report that antipsychotic medications eliminate the 'richness of their mental life' and personality, leading them to prefer experiencing hallucinations over the cognitive and emotional dulling caused by the drugs—a side effect difficult to quantify or describe.
Topics
Transcript
[0:03] The drugs work for some people and they don't work for others. In a significant number of psychotic patients, the are non-drug responders. Just as a significant number of people with depression are not responsive to antidepressants. >> [gasps] >> Moreover, initially the enthusiasm for these drugs everybody neglects the fact that they have serious side effects. Or many of them argue the side effects are an essential part of the treatment and [0:37] you just have to put up with it. So, what are we talking about when I say there are nasty side effects? Well, among others you may become incurably restless. So, you're constantly in motion, you're moving around, you're never never still. If you're in…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Lex Clips
GTA 6 review by biggest jewelry thief in US history | Larry Lawton and Lex Fridman
Larry Lawton, a legendary jewelry thief and FBI's most-wanted criminal, discusses his extensive experience robbing stores while reviewing GTA 6's trailer with Lex Fridman. He provides detailed critiques of the game's accuracy regarding criminal operations, casing techniques, and security vulnerabilities, while reflecting on how his past crimes cost him years with his children.
US war against China or Russia: Why military experts are wrong | Lex Fridman Podcast
Military analysts often make prediction errors by abstracting military power as a simple ranking rather than understanding how forces interact in specific contexts. The Ukraine-Russia war exemplified this, as analysts underestimated Ukrainian military capability and overestimated Russian performance, partly due to having more intelligence on Russian plans than Ukrainian defenses.
Is Putin being lied to? - The distortion of information in Ukraine war | Military Analysis
The transcript discusses how Russian military forces systematically overstate territorial control through false reporting, creating a cascading problem where fabricated battlefield data leads to poor operational decisions, increased casualties, and potentially misinforms political leadership including Putin. The speakers contrast this with Ukrainian practices and explore broader patterns of information distortion in military hierarchies across historical conflicts.
North Korea's role in Ukraine war | Military Analysis - Lex Fridman Podcast
The speaker analyzes how external support sustains both Russia and Ukraine in the war, with North Korea providing significant military aid to Russia. While Russia has resources to continue fighting into 2027, its economy faces structural problems as 44% of government spending goes to military efforts. Ukraine's main vulnerabilities are economic damage, population displacement, and dependency on Western financial, military, and intelligence support that remains subject to shifting political priorities.
Prigozhin's march on Moscow: What really happened | Russia-Ukraine War
The transcript discusses Yevgeny Prigozhin's mutiny with the Wagner Group against Russia's military leadership in 2023, examining the internal elite conflicts that led to the uprising, the failed advance on Moscow, and how Prigozhin's subsequent death demonstrated Putin's elimination of potential rivals. It also analyzes how Wagner's tactics were subsequently adopted across the Russian military after the organization was dismantled.