Jocko Underground: Issues With Training Jiu Jitsu with Women Partners.
Jocko Willink advises a married man concerned about his wife's discomfort with him training jiu-jitsu with women to simply stop rolling with women, prioritizing his marriage over perceived gym etiquette. Echo Charles agrees that while training with women is normal, the intimate physical nature of jiu-jitsu makes the wife's concern understandable and worth respecting.
Summary
A listener asks for advice on a relationship issue: his wife is uncomfortable with him training jiu-jitsu in close positions (mount, closed guard) with female training partners, even though she trusts him completely. She admits to feeling insecure about his training with athletic women. The man rarely trains with women anyway and wonders whether he should simply avoid it or handle the situation differently.
Jocko's response is straightforward: stop training with women. He emphasizes that there is no upside to continuing, no training benefit is gained, and the relationship with his wife and family should be paramount. He stresses that no one in a jiu-jitsu class is obligated to train with anyone else and that declining to roll with certain partners is completely normal and acceptable. He advises the man to simply say no without over-explaining or bringing personal details into the gym conversation—it's between him and his wife.
Echo Charles initially agrees but adds nuance by acknowledging the cultural loyalty aspect some martial artists feel toward their sport and training community. However, he ultimately reinforces that family priorities supersede gym etiquette. Echo notes that while he still trains with women (including world-class athletes like his daughters and professional competitors), he's trained with fewer women over time simply due to fewer women being present in his training circles.
A significant part of their discussion focuses on the physical intimacy of jiu-jitsu. Echo points out that jiu-jitsu is arguably the most physically intimate sport, with positions like mount bearing striking similarities to sexual positions. This observation contextualizes why the wife's concern, while stemming from insecurity, has a legitimate physical basis that doesn't require judgment.
The episode concludes with a transition to promoting Jocko Underground, a subscription service designed to reduce reliance on external platforms and provide better community engagement, priced at $8-18 per month with assistance available for those who cannot afford it.
About this episode
<p><a href="https://app.redcircle.com/shows/64a89f88-a245-4098-8d8d-496325ec4f74/exclusive-content" rel="nofollow"><strong>>Join Jocko Underground Full Episodes<</strong></a></p><p>00:29 — Training Jiu-Jitsu With Women: My wife is uncomfortable with me rolling with women?</p><p>08:55 — Being a Warrior With a Disability?</p><p>16:06 — Regretting Wasted Years: How do I stop regretting lost time and know I'm doing enough?</p><p>23:57 — Dealing With a Disruptive Teenager.</p><p>36:47 — Military Service in the Age of Drones.</p><p><br /></p><br /><br />Support this podcast at — <a href="https://redcircle.com/jocko-podcast/exclusive-content" rel="payment">https://redcircle.com/jocko-podcast/exclusive-content</a>
Key Insights
- Jocko argues that training with women offers no measurable benefit to the questioner since he rarely does it anyway, making the decision to stop a straightforward cost-benefit analysis with zero downside.
- Echo observes that jiu-jitsu is uniquely and arguably the most physically intimate sport, with mount and closed guard positions bearing direct linguistic and positional similarities to sexual positions, which explains why a spouse's concern deserves serious consideration rather than dismissal.
- Both speakers assert that declining to roll with specific training partners is a normal, acceptable practice that requires no explanation or social justification, contrary to what newer practitioners might believe about gym etiquette obligations.
Topics
Transcript
[SPEAKER_00]: This is the Jockel Underground podcast number 233 sitting here with Echo Charles. [SPEAKER_00]: We have a variety of questions from the front line troops. [SPEAKER_00]: Those of you that are out there in the mix currently getting after it, sometimes you run into some obstacles. [SPEAKER_00]: Some terrain features you gotta maneuver around and we are here to answer your questions. [SPEAKER_00]: Give you some solutions. [SPEAKER_00]: give you some recommendations or add a minimum. [SPEAKER_00]: Give you some courses of action you can follow to navigate this terrain of life. [SPEAKER_00]: Let's get into it. [SPEAKER_00]: First question. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm 35, married with kids, and I do just to blue belt. [SPEAKER_01]: Recently, my wife started bringing…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Jocko Podcast
563: The 3 Traits Every Great Leader Must Have According to Gen. Matthew Ridgway
Jocko Willink discusses General Matthew Ridgway's 1966 article on leadership, which identifies three essential traits: character, courage, and competence. The episode explores how these timeless principles apply to modern leadership, military decision-making, and personal development, emphasizing physical fitness, moral courage to challenge flawed orders, and the importance of knowing and being present with one's troops.
562: The Deadly Cost of Bad Leadership. Lessons From Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan. With Bing West
Bing West, a combat Marine veteran and defense analyst who embedded with troops in Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan, discusses the strategic failures and leadership lessons from three decades of American military conflicts. He introduces the 'Jupiter complex'—the arrogance that leads presidents to assume American power is so overwhelming that adversaries will eventually capitulate—as the root cause of lost wars, and offers prescriptions for preventing future strategic failures.
Jocko Underground: When You're Ready For a New Chapter | Battling Fatigue In Life
Jocko Willink discusses two listener questions: whether a 28-year-old E7 military member should leave for civilian careers or stay for retirement, and how someone with chronic fatigue syndrome should balance jiu-jitsu training with their condition. Jocko recommends an iterative approach for the career decision and a "do what you can" protocol for managing training with chronic illness.
561: The Art Of Command. Action, Initiative, and Judgement.
General Melvin Zeiss delivers a 1977 speech on leadership emphasizing that while leadership defies precise definition, the most critical factor is genuine care for those under your command. He argues that successful leaders must balance discipline with respect, prioritize people over processes, and understand that caring about soldiers' welfare—from food quality to psychological support—directly correlates with mission success and personal happiness.
Jocko Underground: My View on Non-Combatant Military Members | How to Get Your Life Back
Jocko Willink and Echo Charles discuss the honorability of non-combatant military service, particularly conscientious objectors who serve as medics, citing Medal of Honor recipients like Desmond Doss. They then address parenting challenges when a gifted child with autism faces peer mockery, emphasizing the importance of building trust and helping children understand that everyone experiences teasing.