Meeting Primary Health Properties CEO: Lee and The IC
Primary Health Properties CEO Mark Davis joins the Investors Chronicle podcast to discuss PHP's 30-year track record of consecutive dividend growth, the transformational merger with Assura, and the company's position as the UK's leading healthcare REIT owning 14% of all primary care real estate. The conversation covers capital structure, growth opportunities tied to NHS reform, and the investment case for PHP as a high-yield income stock.
Summary
The podcast opens with host Alex Newman and veteran private investor John Lee discussing the stabilisation of markets following recent geopolitical tensions, with Lee noting he has been selectively adding to holdings during the dip. The main interview features PHP CEO Mark Davis, who provides a detailed overview of the business: PHP owns 1,100 medical centres across the UK and Ireland, representing 14% of all primary care real estate in the UK and 15% in Ireland. The £6 billion portfolio comprises £5 billion in core primary care assets, £0.3 billion in Ireland, and £0.7 billion in private hospitals acquired through the Assura merger.
Davis addresses PHP's identity as a dividend stock versus a growth company, noting that 80-90% of rent is paid by UK and Irish governments, making it akin to an inflation-linked bond. He confirms official guidance of 3% or more rental income growth annually, with recent results showing 3.4% growth ahead of guidance. John Lee argues the stock is fundamentally mispriced at a 7.5% yield and should trade closer to 5-5.5%, a view Davis endorses, noting PHP historically trades at or above NAV and recently fell to a 10% discount due to geopolitical panic.
The Assura merger is discussed at length. Davis explains the deal was shareholder-driven, with a 40% overlap in shareholder registers, and that PHP successfully competed against KKR and Stonepeak's all-cash bid. The merger doubled PHP's size, accelerated the transition to unsecured borrowing (now two-thirds of debt), and is expected to deliver £9 million or more in synergies. To manage the increased leverage, PHP plans to inject assets into its joint venture with USS (Universities Superannuation Scheme) and establish a new fund for private hospital assets, targeting a loan-to-value of 40-50%.
Davis outlines the growth runway tied to the government's NHS 10-year plan, which prioritises shifting patient services from hospitals to primary care. He notes the Darzi report found 50% of all primary care real estate is unfit for purpose — excluding PHP's portfolio — representing a huge development opportunity. PHP has already secured 3 of the first 26 neighbourhood health centres (11% share), below their 14% market share, with expectations to capture more in future tranches.
On political risk, Davis argues there is rare cross-party consensus on NHS investment, citing that Jeremy Hunt's 2017-18 plan is not materially different from Wes Streeting's current 10-year plan. PHP engages with MPs across all parties and owns assets in nearly every UK constituency. On competition risk, Davis confirms the CMA gave a complete clean bill of health after a thorough review of the Assura deal, with no asset disposals required despite higher-than-average market share in some geographies like West Yorkshire and Gloucestershire.
John Lee raises the long-term takeover risk, noting PHP's uniqueness as the only listed UK healthcare REIT makes it attractive to large global infrastructure funds like KKR and Stonepeak. Davis acknowledges this is a perpetual reality for any non-family-controlled PLC but frames it as opportunity rather than risk, and emphasises management's focus on delivering the dividend king milestone — 50 consecutive years of dividend growth — in 19 years' time.
The podcast closes with Lee discussing Goodwin PLC, whose share price halved following a poorly communicated trading statement that listed lost tenders, deferred Middle East orders, and pessimistic commentary on their Develco polymer business — despite the underlying business remaining solid. Lee sold some shares pre-announcement at around £230 and at £140, but retains a significant position. He also notes positive trading updates from Ampario and Hollywood Bowl as evidence that many of his smaller-cap holdings are performing well operationally despite market volatility.
Key Insights
- Mark Davis argues PHP's 7.5% dividend yield fundamentally misprices the company, stating it should trade at 5-5.5% yield given its inflation-linked income growth, and that pre-crisis PHP traded at a 10% premium to NAV for 27 of its 30 years.
- Davis claims the Darzi report — government-commissioned research — found 50% of all UK primary care real estate is unfit for purpose, excluding PHP's portfolio, which he frames as a structural demand driver for new medical centre development.
- PHP's policy is that 80-90% of its rent roll is paid by UK and Irish governments, which Davis uses to distinguish PHP from a standard bond proxy by describing it as an 'inflation-linked bond' with growing income.
- Davis states that the CMA conducted an extremely thorough review of the Assura merger, did not require any asset disposals or market share reductions despite above-average concentration in areas like West Yorkshire and Gloucestershire, giving PHP confidence it faces no future competition constraints.
- The transition to unsecured borrowing — now two-thirds of PHP's debt post-Assura — has reduced credit margins by 30-40 basis points, with Davis attributing this improvement to scale rather than improved management skill.
- John Lee describes PHP as the premier income stock for private and institutional investors, specifically highlighting its suitability for ISAs and charitable portfolios where the tax-free dividend compounds the already high yield.
- Davis argues cross-party political consensus on NHS investment insulates PHP from political risk, citing that Jeremy Hunt's 2017-18 NHS plan is substantively similar to the current Labour government's 10-year plan under Wes Streeting.
- John Lee attributes Goodwin PLC's share price halving to a communications failure rather than fundamental business deterioration, noting they disclosed lost tenders (rather than lost orders), deferred Gulf orders, and pessimistic Develco commentary without balancing context such as their ongoing Sellafield business and critical US/UK submarine supply contracts.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access