Walter Russell Mead - How America Keeps Winning - [Invest Like the Best, EP.490]
Walter Russell Mead discusses America's historical dominance through maritime commercial strategy, the current crisis in post-WWII institutional order despite strong American technological power, and how personal politics, technological disruption, and great power competition are reshaping global affairs in ways that require a new American social consensus.
Summary
Walter Russell Mead frames American and British power over the past 300 years through a maritime commercial liberal order that has repeatedly defeated continental land-based empires. He traces this through the Dutch (UP), British (UK), and American (US) eras, identifying five strategic elements: an open domestic society that attracts talent and innovation, global trade networks that generate wealth, invitation of others into the system to make it self-sustaining, technological dominance, and the ability to cut off adversaries from global commerce during conflicts. This strategy has succeeded against Louis XIV's France, Napoleonic France, Prussian Germany, Nazi Germany, and the Soviet Union.
Mead argues that while the Pax Americana institutions (NATO, WTO, rules-based order) are collapsing under Trump and others, American power itself remains robust due to information technology dominance and productivity gains. However, this creates an odd paradox: a dynamic country within a crumbling world system. Trump has weaponized unpredictability and celebrity spectacle as power tools, turning shame into irrelevance through industrial-scale norm violation, thereby freeing himself from traditional political constraints while simultaneously dismantling the institutional networks that have carried American influence.
The conversation explores how personal politics is replacing institutional politics globally—Modi in India, Abe in Japan, Erdogan in Turkey, Xi in China, Putin in Russia—marking a return to individual leader-centric power after a 20th-century era of bureaucratic management. Technology, particularly AI, is concentrating power among American companies, creating what Mead calls "tech Hamiltonians" who recognize their interests align with state power and intellectual property protection rather than borderless global commerce.
Mead identifies four recurring American foreign policy traditions (Hamiltonian, Wilsonian, Jeffersonian, Jacksonian) that continue to structure debate. He discusses India as an emerging multipolar power with different civilizational interests, notes the divergence (rather than convergence) of civilizations enabled by information technology, and expresses concern about social class disintegration in America—the collapse of stable industrial working class, institutionalized business, and technocratic expert management—leaving the country unorganized to address serious challenges like AI integration and global stability provision.
On specific conflicts, Mead discusses Ukraine's rapid military adaptation through drone technology and the changing nature of warfare, China's likely incremental approach to Taiwan through soft blockades rather than invasion, and the Middle East's underlying power vacuum where American deterrence has eroded. He argues that deterrence—making consequences certain and unacceptable—has become the critical missing element in American foreign policy, requiring presidential communication that took American people into confidence as Truman and Roosevelt did.
Mead expresses fundamental optimism about the information revolution's capacity to generate abundance in medicine, healthcare, and economic productivity, potentially solving entitlement crises and funding social needs. His main concern is managing the cornucopia of wealth and navigating social stress faster than the wealth appears, requiring new American political and social order foundations. He closes by emphasizing floating on a sea of kindness from mentors and institutions that enabled his work.
About this episode
My guest today is Walter Russell Mead. Walter is a columnist at the Wall Street Journal and the author of Special Providence and God and Gold, two of the best books written on American power. He has spent decades studying how the United States came to dominate the world, and our conversation is about whether it can keep doing so. Walter lays out the five step playbook that carried the Dutch, then the British, then America to global leadership, and why the same pattern keeps beating centralized continental powers. We discuss how Trump turned fame into power, the four schools of American foreign policy and the rise of the tech Hamiltonians, what the drone war in Ukraine means for the Pentagon, and why the erosion of deterrence is the deeper story in the Middle East. Please enjoy my conversation with Walter Russell Mead. For the full show notes, transcript, and links to mentioned content, check out the episode page here. ----- Become a Colossus member to get our quarterly print magazine and private audio experience, including exclusive profiles and early access to select episodes. Subscribe at colossus.com/subscribe. ----- Ramp’s mission is to help companies manage their spend in a way that reduces expenses and frees up time for teams to work on more valuable projects. Go to ramp.com/invest to sign up for free and get a $250 welcome bonus. ----- Trusted by thousands of businesses, Vanta continuously monitors your security posture and streamlines audits so you can win enterprise deals and build customer trust without the traditional overhead. Invest Like the Best listeners get a special offer of $1,000 off Vanta when you go to vanta.com/invest. ----- WorkOS is the infrastructure B2B and AI-native companies use to sell to enterprise. It covers everything enterprise security requires: SSO, SCIM, RBAC, Audit Logs, AI governance, and more. Trusted by 2,000+ fast-growing companies, including OpenAI, Anthropic, Cursor, and Vercel. ----- Rogo is the AI platform for finance. They're building agents for Wall Street that are trained to understand how bankers and investors actually do work: from diligence and modeling, to turning analysis into deliverables. To learn more, visit rogo.ai/invest. ----- Ridgeline has built a complete, real-time, modern operating system for investment managers. It handles trading, portfolio management, compliance, customer reporting, and much more through an all-in-one real-time cloud platform. Visit ridgeline.ai. ----- Editing and post-production work for this episode was provided by The Podcast Consultant. Timestamps: (00:00:00) Welcome to Invest Like the Best (00:02:16) America and the World Today (00:05:34) Trump’s Method of Power (00:09:43) Why America Keeps Winning (00:12:25) The Five-Point Plan for Global Dominance (00:20:11) China and American Power (00:22:10) The Risk of American Isolationism (00:25:50) Technology and Global Power (00:28:42) Riding the Technological Wild Horse (00:34:29) Four Schools of American Foreign Policy (00:40:22) The Rise of Tech Hamiltonians (00:43:51) India and the Next Great Powers (00:48:54) The Risks of the Information Revolution (00:51:30) How Technology Is Changing War (00:55:06) Taiwan (00:57:20) The Future of American Society (01:00:44) What It Means to Be American (01:03:25) Iran and the Middle East (01:06:28) The Erosion of Deterrence (01:08:53) America’s Role in the Next 20 Years (01:12:08) AI and Global Power (01:14:26) Reasons for Optimism (01:16:33) The Kindest Thing
Key Insights
- Mead argues that the maritime commercial liberal order (Dutch, British, American) has defeated continental land empires for 300 years by combining open domestic society, global trade networks, inviting others into the system, technological dominance, and ability to cut adversaries from global commerce.
- Trump has discovered that sufficiently frequent lying eliminates the marginal cost of individual deceptions and has weaponized celebrity spectacle as a form of power that leaves him unconstrained by traditional reputational consequences.
- The post-WWII institutional order (NATO, WTO, rules-based trade) is collapsing while American national power (technological, productive) remains strong, creating a paradox of a dynamic country within a crumbling world system.
- Technology companies now function as 'tech Hamiltonians' with interests aligned to state power and IP protection rather than borderless global commerce, reversing the 1990s assumption that tech transcends national boundaries.
- Personal politics (Modi, Trump, Xi, Abe, Erdogan) is replacing 20th-century institutional and bureaucratic politics globally, marking a return to individual leader-centric power structures.
- Information technology enables civilizational divergence rather than convergence—countries like Turkey, India, and Japan are becoming more distinctly themselves culturally rather than converging to Western models as the Industrial Revolution forced.
- The industrial working class, institutionalized business, and expert technocratic class that structured post-WWII American stability have all collapsed into total disarray, leaving the country unorganized to address serious challenges.
- Deterrence—making adversaries certain that consequences will be terrible and unavoidable—has eroded as American foreign policy practice, replaced by attempts to manage or delay conflicts through institutional mechanisms that no longer function.
- China is likely pursuing incremental steps toward Taiwan (soft blockades, customs assertions of sovereignty) that fly under the American response threshold rather than attempting outright invasion, testing the boundaries of American will.
- Japan's rapid rearmament and strategic reorientation toward defending against China represents an underappreciated factor that complicates China's calculations on Taiwan and could accelerate Japanese capability development.
- Iran could achieve effective hegemony over Middle Eastern oil resources and economic coercion capacity through drone technology targeting desalination plants and infrastructure, making the region uninhabitable rather than through traditional military dominance.
- Information technology is advancing medical research and healthcare cost structures so rapidly that entitlement program sustainability crises may be self-solving through abundance rather than requiring structural reform.
Topics
Transcript
Hello and welcome, everyone. I'm Patrick O'Shaughnessy, and this is Invest Like the Best. This show is an open-ended exploration of markets, ideas, stories, and strategies that will help you better invest both your time and your money. If you enjoy these conversations and want to go deeper, check out Colossus, our quarterly publication with in-depth profiles of the people shaping business and investing. You can find Colossus along with all of our podcasts at colossus.com. You can find Colossus along with all of our podcasts at colossus.com. Patrick O'Shaughnessy is the CEO of Positive Sum. All opinions expressed by Patrick and podcast guests are solely their own opinions and do not reflect the opinion of Positive Sum. This podcast…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy
Sarah Guo - What the 250 People Building AI Believe - [Invest Like the Best, EP.489]
Sarah Guo, founder of Conviction venture capital, discusses her investment strategy focused on the 250 frontier researchers and entrepreneurs shaping AI, her approach to identifying extraordinary people and teams, and her concerns about compute infrastructure, regulatory hurdles, and maintaining Western technological independence in an increasingly competitive global AI landscape.
Neil Movva - Making AI 10x Cheaper - [Invest Like the Best, EP.488]
Neil Movva, founder of SAIL Research, discusses building a 'token factory' designed for long-running AI agents by optimizing across the full stack—software, hardware, and power—to achieve unbeatable cost per token. He argues the future of AI inference will shift from low-latency chatbots to background agents running for hours or days, fundamentally changing GPU optimization priorities from speed to throughput.
Ben Thompson on Big Tech, China, and the AI Boom Running Out of Money - [Invest Like the Best, EP.487]
In this discussion, Ben Thompson shares insights on the AI race between the U.S. and China, the evolving semiconductor industry, and the implications of AI on businesses and economy. He explores how major tech companies like Microsoft, Meta, and NVIDIA are navigating these challenges while impacting their respective fields.
Eric Vishria - A Decade of Lessons Investing in Software & Hardware - [Invest Like the Best, EP.486]
Eric Vishria discusses the evolving landscape of investing in software and hardware, emphasizing the importance of scalable infrastructure in AI and the nuanced role of traditional companies in rapidly changing markets. He shares insights on the complexities of hardware investing, the potential of AI, and the necessary traits for successful partnerships in venture capital.
Gavin Baker - AI Market Jitters - [Invest Like the Best, EP.485]
Gavin Baker discusses the recent market volatility in AI stocks despite improving fundamental metrics, arguing that hyperscalers are under-earning and that operating cash flows will accelerate as GPU contracts reprice higher. He emphasizes that negative sentiment is disconnected from quantitative data showing accelerating demand, token growth, and infrastructure metrics across AI labs and open source models.