STOP opening NEW IIMs | Massive Loan and No Placements
The speaker warns prospective MBA students against joining new or 'baby' IIMs opened in the last 15 years, citing poor placements, unjustifiable ROI, weak alumni networks, and the misleading value of the IIM brand tag. She argues that established non-IIM colleges like XLRI and SP Jain often offer better outcomes than newer IIMs like IIM Amritsar or IIM Bodhgaya.
Summary
The video opens with the announcement of IIM Guwahati in February 2026 as the second IIM in the North Eastern region. While acknowledging this as positive news, the speaker cautions students against joining any of the 15 IIMs opened in the last 15 years solely based on the IIM brand name.
The first and most critical concern raised is placements. The speaker contrasts the 'Holy Trinity' of IIM Ahmedabad, Bangalore, and Calcutta — which achieved 100% placements with an average package of ₹35 lakh even amid global uncertainty and AI-driven layoffs — against newer IIMs. Using RTI-obtained data from IIM Amritsar, she reveals that 78 out of 318 students did not get placed, with those students reportedly 'opting out.' She also mentions IIM Trichy and Kashipur allegedly forcing students to opt out to improve placement statistics. IIM Bodhgaya's minimum package is cited as just ₹4 lakh, and only 10 students from IIM Amritsar's batch of 300+ received packages above ₹20 lakh.
The second point concerns the IIM tag itself. The speaker explains that top consulting firms like McKinsey, BCG, and Bain, as well as legacy FMCG companies like HUL and ITC, recruit almost exclusively from top-tier IIMs. Graduates from newer IIMs, even if hired, tend to be placed in back-end roles rather than client-facing positions. She also notes that IIMs hold virtually no recognition abroad, unlike IITs, making international career prospects extremely limited for most IIM graduates.
The third point is Return on Investment (ROI). IIM Amritsar charges ₹25 lakh in fees despite its poor placement record. When accounting for living expenses in metro cities — where a 3BHK in Mumbai costs at least ₹1 lakh per month — and the fact that reported packages often include bonuses and variable components rather than fixed salary, the financial math does not add up for newer IIMs.
The fourth and final point is the lack of alumni networks at newer IIMs. The speaker argues that the true value of elite institutions lies in their alumni networks — senior professionals in positions of power who can assist with job referrals and career advancement. Baby IIMs simply lack this, and while such networks may develop over 30-40 years, students today bear the risk of that long-term gamble.
The speaker also recommends non-IIM institutions like XLRI Jamshedpur, SP Jain, SIBM Pune, and NMIMS as strong alternatives with average packages above ₹25 lakh. She mentions that these require separate entrance exams (XAT, SNAP, NMAT) beyond CAT, and promotes a test preparation service called Mock Zone for these exams. The video closes with a policy suggestion to the government: keep fees at newer IIMs low until they build strong placement records and alumni networks, rather than using the IIM brand as a profit-making vehicle.
Key Insights
- RTI data from IIM Amritsar reveals that 78 out of 318 students did not receive placements, with the institution reporting them as having 'opted out' — a framing the speaker suggests obscures the true placement failure rate.
- The speaker argues that top consulting firms like BCG hire IIM Ahmedabad graduates for direct client-facing roles, while hires from newer IIMs like IIM Jammu are typically assigned back-end work such as data analysis and presentation preparation — reflecting a significant hierarchy even within IIM recruits.
- IIM Amritsar charges ₹25 lakh in fees and requires a CAT score above 95 percentile, yet only 10 out of 300+ students received packages above ₹20 lakh — making the ROI, in the speaker's view, deeply unjustifiable especially when metro living costs are factored in.
- The speaker states that IIMs are virtually unknown internationally, contrasting them with IITs which have global recognition — arguing that newer IIMs in particular offer almost no pathway to overseas career opportunities.
- The speaker proposes that the government should cap fees at newly established IIMs for 10-15 years and only increase them incrementally based on demonstrated placement performance, arguing that IIMs were created for national development, not as profit-generating institutions.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] नमस्ते एवरीवन। फरवरी 2026 में आईआईएम गुवाहाटी अनाउंस किया गया। यह नॉर्थ ईस्टर्न स्टेट में खोला जाने वाला दूसरा आईआईएम है जो कि बहुत ही खुशी की बात है। लेकिन अगर आप आईआईएम गुवाहाटी या फिर पिछले 10 साल के भीतर खुले किसी भी बेबी आईआईएम को जॉइ करने के बारे में सोच रहे हैं तो मैं आपको वर्न करना चाहूंगी कि केवल आईआईएम टैग के नाम पे अपने फ्यूचर के साथ इतना बड़ा गैंबल आपको नहीं करना है। इसके चार मेजर कारण हैं जिसमें सबसे पहला [0:32] और सबसे इंपॉर्टेंट है प्लेसमेंट। जब हम खबरें सुनते हैं कि आईआईएम के छात्र का 1 करोड़ के एनुअल पैकेज पर सिलेक्शन हुआ है तब हम आईएम अहमदाबाद, बेंगलुरु औरक की…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from IIT-IIM Unfiltered
Zindagi ka Goal - Shaadi
A 27-year-old Indian woman addresses constant social pressure about her unmarried status, explaining three key reasons she refuses to rush into marriage. She discusses financial preparedness for future children, finding the right compatible partner, and resisting societal pressure as her guiding principles.
How I scored 156 in SSC CGL Tier-1 ➤ 3 Honest Strategies and FREE Resources
A consultant who scored 156 in SSC CGL Tier-1 shares her three-pillar strategy for clearing the exam using only free resources and books, without any coaching classes. Her approach centers on taking mocks from Day 1, covering every subject, and maintaining confidence during the exam. She emphasizes analyzing mock tests to identify weak topics and allocating time strategically across subjects.
Social Media Comparison Is Ruining Your Life
A content creator discusses how social media comparison harms mental health by presenting curated, incomplete versions of people's lives. She shares her personal experience of feeling inadequate when comparing herself to others online, and identifies three key factors — incomplete stories, ruthlessness of social media, and exploitation of insecurities — that fuel this damaging cycle. She concludes with practical advice to reduce social media consumption and replace it with reading.
Can you solve IIT-JEE 2026 Question?
A math educator solves an IIT-JEE 2026 trigonometry problem involving a quadratic equation whose roots are tan(a) and tan(b). Using Vieta's formulas and trigonometric identities, the presenter derives the value of 20·sin²((a+b)/2), arriving at the answer 10 - 3√10. The video is framed around the presenter's personal connection to IIT-JEE results from 9 years ago.
Why most IITians are FAILURES | THE HARSH TRUTH
An IIT Patna graduate argues that clearing IIT-JEE does not define a person's success, noting that 50% of her own batch had poor placements despite attending IIT. She contends that India's education system trains students to reach IIT as a final goal, leaving them directionless afterward, which contributes to a lack of major technological innovation from India.