Is Reservation Killing IIT-IIM Placements?
A speaker analyzes IIM Lucknow placement data by category, revealing that General category students achieve higher average placements but some perform poorly, while reserved category students often work harder due to awareness of their disadvantages. The speaker argues that MBA placements are biased toward candidates with strong backgrounds and soft skills, unlike technical fields that prioritize coding skills.
Summary
The speaker discusses placement outcomes at IIM Lucknow broken down by category. In terms of mean (average) placements, General category leads, followed by EWS (Economically Weaker Section), OBC (Other Backward Class), and SC/ST categories, with SC/ST showing approximately 10 lakh rupees gap from General category. However, median analysis (most common placement) shows OBC performing better than EWS, suggesting placement performance correlates with available resources. A critical observation is made about General category students: while the median placement is 40 lakh rupees, the mean falls to 37 lakh rupees because some General category students perform significantly poorly, dragging down the average. The speaker attributes this to a motivational gap—General category students often enter top institutions with confidence but fail to maintain effort, whereas reserved category students work continuously knowing they entered with lower marks and need to prove themselves. The speaker emphasizes that MBA placements are inherently biased compared to technical fields, as they depend heavily on previous educational background, work experience, confidence, and communication skills rather than pure technical ability. The speaker concludes by advocating for viewing all students collectively rather than through categorical distinctions, while acknowledging the overall quality of placements across all categories.
Key Insights
- General category mean placements (37 lakh) are lower than median (40 lakh), indicating that some General category students perform significantly poorly and pull down the average, unlike other categories where this gap doesn't exist
- Reserved category students tend to work harder continuously because they are aware they were selected with lower marks and have inferior background preparation, creating a motivational advantage over General category peers
- MBA placements are biased toward candidates with strong educational backgrounds, previous work experience, confidence, and communication skills, whereas technical/coding fields depend purely on programming ability and data analysis skills
- OBC category median placement performance exceeds EWS category performance despite lower mean placements, suggesting most OBC students perform better than most EWS students even though average outcomes differ
- General category comprises approximately 50% of the batch while OBC, SC/ST, and EWS each represent only 15-20%, making individual performance variation within the General category more impactful on overall statistics
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Hello everyone, does placement in top colleges in India also depend on your category ? In this context, I have got some very good data. During an internal call at IIM Lucknow, their placement committee, for some unknown reason, thought it appropriate to present the data on category-wise placements. However, I do not support this at all. It is [0:30] not right at all to discriminate and separate our students like this. But now that this data is out, there are three very important insights we need to learn from it. First of all, if we look at the order, it will be clearly visible here that the best placement is visible to you under the General category. And…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from IIT-IIM Unfiltered
CAT is harder than RBI Grade B | Best way to prepare for CAT, RBI Grade B, SSC CGL
The speaker discusses the comparative difficulty and competition levels of three major exams: CAT, RBI Grade B, and SSC CGL, highlighting that CAT has the highest quality questions but RBI Grade B presents the toughest competition. He recommends using a specific resource for CAT preparation.
How I saved 1 CRORE at 27
A 27-year-old shares how he saved ₹1 crore by mastering five principles: understanding consumerism and brand manipulation, avoiding social comparison, creating friction between himself and shopping, maintaining emergency savings, and staying completely away from loans. He argues that modern consumer culture exploits insecurities while society conditions people to spend money they don't have.
Punjabi Singers and Lack of Morality
A critic analyzes how Punjabi singer Karan Aujla promotes Stake, an illegal online gambling platform in India, through his social media and lifestyle posts. The speaker argues that celebrities endorsing such platforms send harmful messages to youth about earning wealth through morally questionable means.
Why You Should Stop Watching YouTube (Yes, Even This Video)
A content creator who recently struggled with YouTube addiction identifies three key reasons that helped him overcome it: prioritizing learning-by-doing over passive consumption, eliminating access to YouTube across all devices, and protecting concentration by avoiding social media breaks. He argues that watching educational content without implementation is wasteful, and that even brief social media consumption disrupts focus for 23 minutes.
My Resume That Got Selected at GOOGLE, AMAZON, BCG & McKinsey
A resume review explaining how the speaker secured interviews at major tech companies (Google, Amazon, BCG, McKinsey) by focusing on three key elements: project-heavy experience, quantifiable metrics/numbers, and crisp one-page formatting. The speaker also promotes Scaler School of Business's 18-month program that emphasizes AI, business, and real-world project building.