Heptabase PDF Review: Obsidian and Scrintal Don't Win
The speaker demonstrates Heptabase's powerful PDF annotation and research workflow, showing how highlights can be extracted, connected across whiteboards, and integrated with other notes to create a comprehensive personal knowledge management system that rivals tools like Obsidian and Scrintal.
Summary
The speaker, an experienced PKM system tester with over a decade of experience, showcases Heptabase as their preferred knowledge management tool. They highlight how Heptabase combines the best features of competing tools including Scrintal, Obsidian, Tana, and MarginNote's PDF annotation capabilities. The core demonstration focuses on a sophisticated PDF research workflow using a PhD thesis as an example. Users can upload PDFs as cards, highlight text or areas (particularly useful for images), and add notes to these highlights. The key innovation is the drag-and-drop functionality that allows users to extract highlights directly onto whiteboards, visually representing connections between different pieces of information. The system tracks where highlights appear across multiple whiteboards through an info panel, enabling users to navigate between contexts. When reading through PDFs, users can locate highlights in their original source with a single click, which automatically opens the PDF and scrolls to the relevant section. All connections are bidirectional—emails, notes, and other content can be linked to highlights, creating an interconnected web of information. The speaker emphasizes that this isn't an isolated feature but deeply integrates with daily journaling, allowing users to review past notes and see how they connect to research highlights. The speaker concludes by inviting viewers to join the Heptabase Mastery course, which teaches how to leverage these features as a core PKM system across various workflows.
Key Insights
- The speaker has tested digital PKM systems for over a decade and identifies Heptabase as their all-time favorite tool because it synthesizes the best aspects of multiple competing platforms like Scrintal, Obsidian, Tana, and MarginNote
- Heptabase's PDF highlighting feature allows users to drag and drop highlighted text or area-based annotations directly onto whiteboards, enabling visual representation of connections between different research findings
- The system maintains bidirectional connections where a single highlight can appear across multiple whiteboards, and clicking the info section reveals all contexts where that highlight is referenced
- Users can locate any highlight within its original PDF source with one click, which automatically opens the PDF and scrolls to the exact position where the highlight was created
- The PDF research workflow integrates with daily journaling, allowing users to review past journal entries and discover connections between those notes and research highlights they created
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] I've been testing digital personal knowledge management systems and note-taking apps for over a decade. [music] During that time, one handwriting iPad app really stood out to me, MarginNote. I loved [music] this approach to annotating PDFs, even though it lacked many other features. If you follow me on this channel, you know that Hepta Base has become my all-time favorite PKM tool. It combines the best aspects of so many other tools like Scrintal, Obsidian, and Tana, and I want to add MarginNote to that list, too. [0:32] I've shown this PDF annotation method in one-on-one sessions with many of our Paperless Movement members, lawyers, doctors, and project managers alike, and they immediately saw its potential for enhancing…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from ICOR with Tom | AI Productivity
I Can Build a $11 Billion Productivity App with AI (You Can Too)
The speaker demonstrates how modern AI models (Claude Sonnet 3.5) enable anyone to build sophisticated productivity applications without extensive coding knowledge, using the newly rebuilt myICOR membership platform as proof. He argues that pre-built platforms like Notion, Circle, and Mighty Networks are becoming obsolete as AI democratizes custom application development, and announces a live workshop teaching the conceptual and technical skills needed to build such apps.
I gave Claude 4 years of our work. It built this app.
A developer used Claude Sonnet 5.5 to build a fully functional ICOR-based productivity application in just one hour by providing the AI with four years of accumulated productivity knowledge and content. The resulting app successfully implements complex ICOR methodology concepts including inbox management, task prioritization, interruption handling, and life dimension tracking, though it needs UI/design refinement.
Claude just replaced every productivity app I use.
A content creator demonstrates how Claude's Sonnet 3.5 model with Code Interpreter can replace multiple productivity apps by building three fully-functional applications in under an hour with minimal prompting. The creator showcases a note-taking app with database features, a Mac application integrating their custom Obsidian plugins and ICOR life management methodology, and highlights the unprecedented speed and polish achievable without traditional development skills.
My AI team took 8 hours. Claude Sonnet 5.5 took 15 minutes.
A creator comparing an 8-hour AI team project with a 15-minute Claude Sonnet 5.5 solution reveals that excessive guardrails and restrictions paradoxically hindered the multi-agent system's performance. The speaker demonstrates how reducing constraints and context allows AI to produce more creative and functional results, though both approaches have significant limitations for production use.
Your knowledge should outlive every AI tool you use.
The speaker clarifies the distinction between the ICOR methodology (a tool-agnostic productivity framework) and its implementations like the ICOR for Life scaffold and myPKA AI team, emphasizing that users can adopt the core principles in any tool they prefer. They announce plans to restructure their membership platform by separating these components to reduce confusion and help users understand they're not locked into specific tools or systems.