StoryInsightful

Good Culture: How Jesse Merrill Made Cottage Cheese Cool

How I Built This with Guy Raz1h 18m

Jesse Merrill, founder of Good Culture cottage cheese, built a $200M+ brand by combining his background in experiential marketing with a mission-driven approach to revitalizing a declining food category. After personal health challenges prompted him to focus on clean-label nutrition, he methodically executed his vision for eight years before a viral TikTok moment with influencer Lainey Cook catapulted the brand into the mainstream.

Summary

Jesse Merrill's journey to founding Good Culture began unconventionally. After college, he worked as a PA for director Jonathan Demme, then moved to Los Angeles to work on MTV's Jackass with Spike Jones. While struggling financially in that role, he took brand ambassador jobs passing out product samples—including KY lubricant on San Diego beaches—which led him to appreciate the sophistication of experiential marketing and CPG brand building.

This early exposure to marketing led to increasingly significant roles. He worked on Moby's tea brand Teenie in New York, learning the full spectrum of brand building from point-of-sale materials to shelf space negotiations. When Teenie was sold, Honest Tea recruited him to expand into the New York metro market. There, he partnered with founder Seth Goldman to launch Honest Kids and eventually scaled the company to $75-80M in revenue before Coca-Cola acquired it in 2011.

After Honest Tea, Merrill joined Anders Eisner (son of former Disney CEO Michael Eisner) to build Activate Drinks, an enhanced water brand with proprietary twist-cap vitamin delivery technology. Despite $12M+ in funding, the brand only achieved $5M in revenue before losing investor backing from Tata Group in 2013 and being sold to a Canadian company.

The Good Culture concept emerged in 2014 when Merrill noticed his pregnant wife eating cottage cheese for its protein content, triggering his realization that cottage cheese—once larger than yogurt in the 1970s—had been neglected by the industry. Around the same time, he was diagnosed with ulcerative colitis, a diagnosis he managed through diet rather than medication, which deepened his focus on clean-label, nutritionally superior food products.

Merrill and Anders co-founded Good Culture in 2014, securing support from co-manufacturers despite challenges: most cottage cheese producers had pivoted to yogurt, most demanded high minimum order quantities, and many lacked organic certification or single-serve filling capabilities. After kitchen experimentation with different textures and flavors, they found a Wisconsin co-packer willing to collaborate. The brand launched at Expo West in March 2015 with packaging that featured cottage cheese prominently—a critical learning after early consumer confusion with yogurt.

Initial distribution was modest: 55 Whole Foods stores and all Sprouts locations. Merrill spent the next six years grinding through grassroots marketing, sampling, and influencer seeding. The brand expanded to national Whole Foods distribution by January 2016. By 2021, Good Culture had reached $70M in revenue through expanded distribution into Kroger and Walmart, coupled with targeted influencer partnerships and PR efforts.

The turning point came in 2023 when health influencer Lainey Cook posted a viral TikTok video showing how to make 60-gram protein ice cream by blending Good Culture cottage cheese with honey. The video sparked an exponential viral cascade across TikTok and other platforms, with creators developing variations (flatbreads, bagels, smoothies, pasta dishes). This moment introduced Gen Z to cottage cheese as an aspirational, trendy food product and created nationwide shortages.

The category expansion was dramatic: U.S. cottage cheese market grew from $1B in 2014 to $2.4B by 2025, with per capita consumption recovering from 1.4-1.5 pounds to 2.4-2.5 pounds (approaching 1970s levels of 5 pounds). Good Culture grew to over $200M in annual revenue by end of 2025, though this represented less than 50% of actual demand due to supply chain capacity constraints.

Facing explosive demand and capacity limitations, rather than continuously raising venture capital, Merrill partnered with private equity firm Elf Catterton in 2026, bringing in majority investment to fund manufacturing expansion and allow him to focus on brand, innovation, and commercial strategy. The partnership closed in 2026, with Merrill remaining as CEO.

About this episode

Jesse Merrill wanted to make movies. Instead, he made cottage cheese cool—and built a business with more than $200 million in annual sales. Jesse got his start fetching coffee on the set of Jackass and handing out product samples for extra cash. After helping build Moby’s tea brand and grow Honest Tea, he teamed up with cofounder Anders Eisner to reinvent cottage cheese. But Good Culture got off to a rocky start. The first batch came out soupy. Shoppers mistook it for yogurt. And Jesse had just 30 days to sell his inventory at Whole Foods or risk paying for what didn't sell. Then a cottage cheese ice cream recipe went viral on TikTok, introducing millions of people to a food they'd long overlooked. What You’ll Learn How Jesse's early marketing gigs prepared him to build a consumer brand Why he bet on a category with aging customers and declining sales How Good Culture's early packaging confused shoppers How Jesse tackled a manufacturing crisis as demand soared What he looked for in an investment partner to help Good Culture scale Production Credits How I Built This is produced by Podcast Pointman and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Follow How I Built This: YouTube → @HowIBuiltThis Instagram → @howibuiltthis X → @HowIBuiltThis Facebook → How I Built This Follow Guy Raz: Instagram → @guy.raz X → @guyraz Substack → guyraz.substack.com Website → guyraz.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Key Insights

  • Merrill learned CPG brand building through unconventional sampling jobs (including KY lubricant distribution) before transitioning into formal marketing roles, demonstrating how experiential marketing teaches consumer psychology and brand storytelling.
  • His diagnosis with ulcerative colitis in 2015 validated his hypothesis that cottage cheese could be reformulated with clean ingredients to address real health needs, turning personal experience into market insight.
  • Good Culture faced a critical packaging design problem early on where consumers mistook the single-serve cups for yogurt, requiring prominent visual cottage cheese imagery on the front to overcome category confusion.
  • The brand required 8-10 units sold per store per week at Whole Foods to maintain shelf space, with a 45-day shelf life that became 30 days in-store, forcing Merrill to personally monitor store codes and coordinate emergency sampling teams to prevent spoilage.
  • Before virality, Merrill built the brand through eight years of deliberate influencer seeding and grassroots sampling, creating the conditions for the viral moment rather than relying on chance.
  • The cottage cheese category declined from larger than yogurt in the 1970s to less than 1.5 pounds per capita consumption by 2015, yet Merrill identified it as an opportunity because it checked multiple mega-trend boxes: high protein, low sugar, clean label, and gut health.
  • The viral TikTok moment specifically resonated with Gen Z (not just millennials or Gen X) because it presented cottage cheese as inherently cool through an aspirational influencer's recipe innovation, rather than requiring education about functional benefits.
  • Viral content on TikTok created a category-wide cottage cheese shortage as all competitors benefited from demand explosion, but Good Culture captured disproportionate share due to appearing in Lainey Cook's original video.
  • Despite reaching $200M+ revenue by end of 2025, Good Culture was servicing less than 50% of actual market demand due to manufacturing capacity constraints, making the revenue figure more reflective of supply limitations than market penetration.
  • Rather than pursuing additional venture capital raises despite being highly profitable, Merrill opted for majority private equity investment from Elf Catterton to secure experienced operational partners for supply chain scaling.
  • Merrill's background working for famous figures (Jonathan Demme, Spike Jones, Moby, Seth Goldman) taught him that authenticity and mission-driven leadership attract talent and partners, informing how he built Good Culture's culture.
  • The cottage cheese market expanded from $1B in 2014 to $2.4B by 2025 (140% growth), with per capita consumption moving from 1.4 pounds to 2.4 pounds, demonstrating how product innovation and effective marketing can revitalize entire categories.

Topics

Brand building and experiential marketingCareer trajectory from film industry to CPG entrepreneurshipProduct innovation in declining categoriesHealth challenges as business inspirationClean label and organic food productionInfluencer marketing and viral momentsSupply chain and manufacturing constraintsCategory revival and market expansionPrivate equity partnership and scalingFounder-led mission-driven business

Transcript

When you launch into a Whole Foods, you're on full reclamation, right, for like six months. So like anything that doesn't sell, you have to buy back. You have to sell eight to ten tubs of this per store per week, which doesn't sound like a lot, but it's a lot. It is. It was very hard. It was incredibly stressful for me. I was monitoring as many stores as I could. I would drive into stores and I would look at the codes and I would see there was only a few days left and the shelf was still stocked and in a panic I would call our brand ambassador and tell them they have to immediately get a…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from How I Built This with Guy Raz

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.