Advice Line with Eric Ryan of Method returns
Eric Ryan, co-founder of Method and now a venture investor at Greycroft, joins Guy Raz to advise three early-stage founders on brand building, marketing, and fundraising strategy. The callers pitch an allergen-free fragrance brand, a customizable kids' flip-flop company, and an illuminated crystal jewelry line. Eric emphasizes brand-building over product novelty and community over capital-raising as recurring themes.
Summary
The episode opens with Guy Raz introducing Eric Ryan, who has recently transitioned from serial entrepreneurship to venture investing by joining Greycroft and launching a new $150 million consumer-focused fund. Eric reflects on the shift from being a founder who 'gets sacked' to playing the role of coach and investor. He discusses the current investment climate for consumer packaged goods (CPG), noting that a wave of tech money entering the space around 2020-2021 inflated valuations and encouraged unsustainable growth, leading to a market reset. He argues the reset creates a good entry point for disciplined consumer investing, and that finding brands capable of reaching $100-200 million in revenue is the key challenge.
The first caller, Christina Pang, founder of Haven Beauty in San Diego, presents a fine fragrance and skincare brand formulated without the 82 known fragrance allergens, targeting the estimated 30+ million Americans with eczema and 100+ million who identify as having sensitive skin. Her core challenge is re-educating consumers—and even dermatologists—who have been trained to avoid fragrance entirely. Eric advises her to pursue a dual-audience strategy: appeal broadly to consumers seeking 'better for you' fragrances while also serving those with genuine allergies. He cautions against focusing exclusively on the allergy-specific audience, as re-education is a slow and difficult process. He also suggests positioning Haven not just as a brand but as the creator of a new category—'allergen-free fragrance'—and recommends pitching to retailers like Ulta around building a dedicated category destination. Guy adds that clinical studies and dermatologist endorsements could significantly bolster consumer trust.
The second caller, James Chambliss, founder of Pigeon Toes in Orange County, has built a customizable kids' flip-flop brand focused on comfort, featuring a soft toe cord and a choose-your-own color and strap design system. With roughly $15,000 in early sales, his question centers on how to build brand awareness against better-resourced competitors. Eric praises the customization concept as the brand's strongest asset and suggests leaning into licensing children's characters to drive content and freshness. Both Eric and Guy converge on the idea of turning the product into a live experiential offering—deploying event teams to hotels and resorts during peak vacation seasons to let kids design their own flip-flops on-site. This approach would generate organic content, create memorable family experiences, and differentiate Pigeon Toes from mass-market competitors. Eric frames the brand's ultimate identity as selling 'summer' rather than flip-flops.
The third caller, Ben Forrest, founder of Reserved for Humans based in DeLand, Florida, has developed the Spire Pendant—a light-up crystal necklace that illuminates the hidden textures of natural stone. After a soft launch in August, he generated $92,000 in December revenue alone before pausing operations to travel to China to set up factory production and third-party logistics. He asks whether to raise outside capital now to defend against fast-follower competition. Eric is direct: the product is not defensible on its own and can be replicated, but a strong brand built around community and self-expression could create a durable moat. He reframes the product's core value as enabling people to express their mood or energy in real time—calling it a 'modern-day mood ring'—and argues that this emotional and community-oriented brand identity is what investors and consumers will ultimately pay for. Both Eric and Guy advise against raising capital at this stage, recommending instead that Ben take investor meetings for learning and relationship-building without pressure, and focus first on proving revenue consistency and building brand.
In a closing reflection, Eric shares that the most consistent theme across all three callers—and across his own entrepreneurial journey—is the mental game of confidence. He notes that as a venture investor, much of his role now resembles a therapist or coach, helping founders stay focused and self-assured when things get hard.
Key Insights
- Eric Ryan argues that the post-2020 CPG market reset—caused by inflated tech-money valuations encouraging unsustainable growth—has actually created a good entry point for disciplined consumer investing, particularly for brands that can realistically reach $100-200 million in revenue.
- Eric contends that re-educating consumers is significantly harder than educating them, and advises Haven Beauty to run two parallel strategies: attracting general 'better for you' fragrance seekers while slowly converting allergy-sufferers, rather than focusing exclusively on the allergic population.
- Eric suggests that Haven Beauty should position itself not merely as a brand but as the founder of a new retail category—'allergen-free fragrance'—and pitch retailers like Ulta on building a dedicated category destination anchored by Haven as its leader.
- Eric argues that for Pigeon Toes, customization is the single most important strategic asset because it drives content creation organically, and recommends layering licensed children's characters onto the customization model to accelerate brand relevance and retail appeal.
- Both Eric and Guy independently converge on the idea that Pigeon Toes is fundamentally an experiential business, and that deploying event teams at hotels and resorts during vacation season would simultaneously drive sales, generate content, and differentiate the brand in ways that a purely digital strategy cannot.
- Eric tells Ben Forrest bluntly that the Spire Pendant is not a defensible product on its own because it can be replicated, but argues that building a brand around community and real-time emotional self-expression—framing it as a 'modern-day mood ring'—is the moat that would make it defensible.
- Eric advises Ben not to frame his decision as 'raise capital or don't raise capital,' but instead to take investor meetings purely for learning and relationship-warming, noting that the right time to raise money is when you don't need it, and that investors who are excited will offer to invest without being asked.
- Eric reflects that across his entire career and all the founders he now works with, the most persistent and underestimated challenge is not financial or operational risk, but the mental game of maintaining self-confidence—and that much of his role as a VC is effectively playing therapist to help founders stay focused.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access