When Bad Things Happen to Good People
The episode explores how people respond to tragedy and suffering through interviews with historian Kate Bowler, who was diagnosed with stage 4 cancer at age 35, and psychologist Lisa Miller, who studies spirituality from a neuroscientific perspective. Both discuss how cultural beliefs about fairness and control shape our reactions to adversity, and how spiritual practices can help people navigate life's uncertainties.
Summary
The episode begins with Kate Bowler's personal account of being diagnosed with stage 4 colon cancer despite living what she considered a perfect life—a tenured position at Duke University, a loving marriage, and a newborn son. Bowler describes how her diagnosis shattered deeply held assumptions about how the world works: that good choices lead to good outcomes, that the world is fair, and that effort and planning can control destiny.
Bowler analyzes the various ways people responded to her illness, categorizing them as 'minimizers' (those who downplay suffering with phrases like 'at least'), 'teachers' (those who offer lessons or solutions), and 'solutions people' (those uncomfortable with uncertainty and always seeking new treatments). She traces these responses to cultural and religious traditions, particularly the American prosperity gospel—a 19th-century religious movement based on New Thought philosophy that claims positive thinking and words can create reality. This theology suggests that suffering results from insufficient faith or inadequate positive thinking, placing blame on the sufferer.
Bowler explains that many people respond to tragedy by trying to impose order and meaning on randomness. She notes the tension between the 'porous self' (open to both good and bad) and the 'buffered self' (sealed off as a self-improvement project), drawing on philosopher Charles Taylor's concepts. She advocates for embracing ambiguity, asking for help, and finding joy in absurdity rather than seeking constant improvement.
The second part features psychologist Lisa Miller discussing her research on spirituality and the brain. Miller describes three neural networks activated during spiritual experiences, whether through prayer, meditation, or nature, that create a perception of being loved, held, guided, and never alone. She emphasizes that these circuits are universal across religious traditions and that spirituality differs from mere belief—it is a direct, perceived relationship with a transcendent source.
Miller discusses how suffering often serves as a 'knock at the door' to spiritual deepening and presents research showing people exposed to hardship are 250% more likely to develop spiritual practices. She explores the relationship between intuition and spiritual guidance, describing intuition as 'direct knowing' rather than mere brain construction, and discusses synchronicities as moments revealing deeper meaning.
The episode includes listener testimonies describing spiritual experiences, including moments of divine guidance, healing, and transformation. Miller emphasizes that spirituality can be developed through service to others, which literally strengthens brain regions associated with spiritual perception. She also addresses how to distinguish between imposed religious trauma and authentic spiritual practice, arguing that true spirituality aligns with feelings of being loved and held rather than fear and exclusion.
About this episode
When historian Kate Bowler was diagnosed with Stage IV cancer, she became fascinated by the ways people try to impose order on events they can't control. She joins us to explore what it means to live fully when life offers no satisfying explanation for the tragedies we may face. Then, in the latest installment of "Your Questions Answered," psychologist Lisa Miller returns to answer listener questions about the relationship between science and spirituality.
Key Insights
- Kate Bowler argues that people unconsciously hold assumptions that good choices lead to good outcomes and that the world is fair, assumptions that are destabilized by sudden tragedy and create profound disorientation.
- Bowler identifies a pattern where responses to others' suffering often attempt to impose order on randomness: academic friends research genetic mutations, health-conscious friends suggest dietary causes, and religious friends offer spiritual explanations, all trying to create causality where none exists.
- The American prosperity gospel, rooted in 19th-century New Thought philosophy, teaches that positive thinking and speech can create reality, implying that suffering results from inadequate faith or incorrect thoughts, thereby blaming the sufferer.
- Bowler distinguishes between the 'porous self' (open to both good and bad experiences) and the modern 'buffered self' (sealed off as a self-improvement project), arguing that psychological armor against pain also prevents people from experiencing beauty and meaning.
- Lisa Miller's neuroscience research demonstrates that three specific brain networks are universally activated during spiritual experiences across different religious traditions, creating a perception of being loved, held, guided, and never alone.
- Miller's longitudinal research found that people over 35 who experienced significant hardship were 250% more likely to develop spiritual practices, suggesting suffering serves as a catalyst for spiritual deepening.
- Miller describes spirituality as a direct, perceived relationship with a transcendent source rather than merely a belief system, and emphasizes this distinction is fundamental to understanding how spirituality differs from faith traditions.
- Service to others literally strengthens the brain regions associated with spiritual perception, making service the most effective spiritual practice for cultivating spiritual awareness according to Miller's research.
- Miller argues that the brain functions as a conduit or antenna for consciousness rather than merely a factory that constructs thoughts, which reframes intuition and synchronicity as forms of direct knowing rather than cognitive artifacts.
- Bowler describes experiencing rage-filled prayers at 2 a.m. versus reasonable, nuanced prayers at 2 p.m., illustrating how suffering strips away social politeness and reveals raw, honest spiritual expression.
- Miller states that authentic spiritual practice must align with feelings of being loved, held, and guided, and that practices creating fear, exclusion, or violation of love represent human distortions rather than true spirituality.
- Bowler argues that asking for help is crucial during suffering because people derive meaning and satisfaction from being useful to others, and refusing help deprives others of this relational opportunity.
Topics
Transcript
This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedanta. In 1759, the French writer and philosopher Voltaire published a satirical novel about a young man and his tutor. Pangloss, the tutor, instructs the student, Candide, that they live in, quote, the best of all possible worlds. As the story unfolds, Candide witnesses war, disease, natural disasters, torture, and death. Pangloss encounters many of these tragedies himself. Yet, no matter what happens, he continues to insist that everything is unfolding exactly as it should. It's from this character that we get the word Panglossian, describing someone who relentlessly maintains that everything is for the best. Most of us are not as optimistic as Pangloss. But many of us do carry assumptions in our…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Hidden Brain
How to Make a Difference: Part 2
Martin Seligman discusses how people develop agency—the belief that their actions can create change—and argues that this capacity is a learnable skill rather than an innate trait. Through research and practical techniques, Seligman explains how shifting explanatory styles, building efficacy through small wins, and using imagination can help people overcome learned helplessness and flourish.
How to Make a Difference: Part 1
Martin Seligman discusses his research on learned helplessness and agency, explaining how people's explanatory styles—whether they view setbacks as temporary or permanent—shape their resilience, motivation, and life outcomes. He argues that the development of agency as a concept throughout human history has been the psychological driver behind human progress and innovation.
Why Conversations Go Wrong
This transcript explores how conversational style differences—shaped by culture, region, and upbringing—create misunderstandings in relationships, from intimate partnerships to professional settings. Linguist Deborah Tannen examines why these miscommunications occur automatically and unconsciously, and psychologist Emma Levine discusses the complex ethics of pro-social lying, revealing when deception may be justified to protect others.
Blowing Up Your Life
Hidden Brain explores 'jolts'—unexpected moments that jolt us out of autopilot and force us to reassess our lives and careers. Psychologist Anthony Klotz discusses how these moments can drive major decisions like quitting jobs, while Arp Dijkstrahaus explains how inspiration and unconscious thought processes help us solve problems and find creative breakthroughs.
The Things We Don't Say
Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker discusses why people use indirect speech rather than saying exactly what they mean, exploring how language serves dual purposes: communicating information while establishing social relationships. Through examples ranging from fundraising dinners to diplomatic exchanges, Pinker explains that indirectness often protects relationships and dignity, though it can sometimes have tragic consequences.