Do You Feel Loved?
Psychologist Sonia Lubomirsky explores the gap between being loved and feeling loved, arguing that common strategies like self-promotion, hiding flaws, and manipulation are counterproductive. The episode also features Stanford psychologist Greg Walton discussing how negative thought spirals form and how proximal goals, expressive writing, and social support can help break them. Both researchers emphasize that genuine curiosity, listening, and vulnerability are more effective paths to connection than performance.
Summary
The episode opens with a reference to Shakespeare's Merchant of Venice, using Portia's casket test as a metaphor for modern love-testing behaviors — dropping hints, withholding texts, acting distant — and framing these as manipulative strategies that undermine the very connection people seek.
Psychologist Sonia Lubomirsky, who studies what people do to feel loved at UC Riverside, is the primary guest in the first half. Drawing on a survey of nearly 2,000 people, she and co-author Harry Rees found that approximately 70% of respondents reported at least one relationship in which they did not feel as loved as they wished. Lubomirsky argues this figure is likely an understatement, and that the gap between being loved and feeling loved is widespread, extending beyond romantic relationships to friendships, family, and even workplace settings.
Lubomirsky shares personal anecdotes to illustrate the research: a date who spent the entire drive showcasing his Tesla rather than connecting; another date who told entertaining stories for 45 minutes without asking her a single question; a former partner whose slow texting response times made her feel uncared for, ultimately ending the relationship; and her own adult daughter whose limited emotional sharing left Lubomirsky feeling unloved despite knowing she was loved.
The episode then explores the faulty strategies people use to feel more loved: self-promotion (showcasing wealth, beauty, or accomplishments), hiding vulnerabilities and flaws, manipulating others into performing love (illustrated by the Brooke and Gary scene from The Breakup), and using social media to project idealized versions of themselves. Lubomirsky argues these strategies are rooted in performance rather than genuine connection, and that people deeply crave being known — including their contradictions and blemishes — as a prerequisite to feeling truly loved.
Lubomirsky introduces the 'sea-saw' metaphor (spelled with 'sea' to evoke being partially submerged in water), where two people are sitting on opposite ends of an underwater seesaw. Most people show only a small portion of themselves — their polished surface — to others. When one person demonstrates genuine curiosity and warmth, they metaphorically press down on the seesaw, lifting the other person up and making them feel safe enough to reveal more of themselves. This reciprocal dynamic of lifting and being lifted is what she argues creates genuine connection and the feeling of being loved.
Key positive strategies discussed include: asking deep, personal questions; practicing high-quality listening (listening to learn rather than to respond); maintaining an open heart toward others; and making the other person feel loved first, rather than waiting to receive love before giving it. The reciprocity norm — one of the strongest principles in human social behavior — is central to this framework. Lubomirsky notes that when she applied these principles to her relationship with her adult daughter, asking more questions and following up on things that mattered to her daughter, the relationship gradually became warmer and more reciprocal.
The second half of the episode shifts to Stanford psychologist Greg Walton, author of 'Ordinary Magic,' who answers listener questions about negative thought spirals. Walton explains the concept of 'tiff bits' — small pieces of information that get blown out of proportion — and how our tendency to read the world from a self-referential perspective causes us to over-interpret others' behavior as being about us. He discusses how people in positions of power (parents, teachers, bosses) have an outsized influence on others' self-perception and becoming, citing a powerful example from the French film 'The Class.'
Walton emphasizes the concept of 'becoming' — the ongoing process of developing into the person one wants to be — and how spirals are fundamentally threats to that process. Practical strategies discussed include: proximal goals (breaking large challenges into small, manageable steps, as researched by Al Bandura); expressive writing (Jamie Pennebaker's intervention of writing about unprocessed thoughts to create a narrative with a beginning, middle, and end); predefined check-in points (to avoid constant meta-questioning that distracts from actually engaging with life); growth mindset framing (treating failure as 'not yet' rather than evidence of fixed inability); and leaning on others, since humans are fundamentally social animals who cannot escape spirals alone.
The episode closes with a listener named Sherry sharing how she escaped suicidal ideation by making 'love lists' — lists of reasons she loved her mother — which she found crowded out the looping negative thoughts. Walton affirms that reconnecting with authentic close relationships is among the most powerful antidotes to negative spirals.
Key Insights
- Lubomirsky argues that roughly 70% of people report at least one relationship in which they do not feel as loved as they want to be, and she believes this figure is an understatement.
- Lubomirsky distinguishes between being loved and feeling loved, arguing that a person can be genuinely loved while still failing to perceive or internalize that love.
- Lubomirsky contends that common strategies for obtaining love — showcasing wealth, beauty, or accomplishments — may impress others but do not create genuine felt connection or the experience of being loved.
- Lubomirsky argues that hiding one's flaws and vulnerabilities backfires because it prevents the experience of being loved unconditionally; people who hide their blemishes will always wonder if they would still be loved if truly known.
- Lubomirsky and Rees concluded that to feel more loved, people do not need to change themselves or the other person — they need to change the conversation, making it less performative and more revealing of inner selves.
- Lubomirsky argues that the counterintuitive first step to feeling loved is to make the other person feel loved by showing genuine curiosity and listening deeply, relying on the reciprocity norm to generate a mutual dynamic.
- Lubomirsky describes the 'sea-saw' metaphor: when one person shows warmth and asks meaningful questions, the other person feels safe enough to reveal more of themselves, which then prompts reciprocal openness and lifts both people.
- Lubomirsky describes Marco, the best listener she had ever met, as someone who listened to learn rather than to respond — remembering specific details from past conversations — which made others feel deeply cared for and seen.
- Walton argues that negative spirals are fundamentally threats to a person's sense of 'becoming' — their hopes and trajectory toward the kind of person they want to be — which is why they generate such intense fear and anxiety.
- Walton found that role model stories are most effective when they depict a process of growth from a dark or failing place, rather than stories of triumph and success, because growth narratives connect with the real difficulty people are experiencing.
- Walton cites Al Bandura's research showing that breaking a large goal into proximal, manageable sub-goals — such as six math pages per day instead of an open-ended total — increases both confidence and performance by generating small, repeated experiences of progress.
- Walton argues that people who have power over us — parents, teachers, bosses — have an outsized influence on our self-perception, meaning both devastation and extraordinary empowerment can come from a single word or gesture from such figures.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access