Is Arsenal's cup record a cause for concern?
Arsenal suffered an embarrassing 5-3 penalty shootout loss to Fleetwood Town in the Carabao Cup, with hosts Ian Stone, Art de Rocher, and James McNicholas analyzing the poor performance, team selection decisions, and the fallout including Max Dowman's red card and Mikel Arteta's public criticism of the young player.
Summary
The podcast opens with discussion of Arsenal's shocking Carabao Cup elimination to Fleetwood Town, a team 18th in League Two, in a penalty shootout after a 1-1 draw. The hosts describe the performance as one of the worst they've witnessed, particularly given Arsenal's strong position in the Premier League before this match. They praise Fleetwood's defensive approach and team organization while criticizing Arsenal's lack of creativity, poor execution, and insipid attacking play.
Regarding team selection, James McNicholas questions whether Kai Havertz should have started instead of either Eze or Ødegaard at the number 10 position. Art de Rocher defends the rotation strategy, citing that Arteta was managing minutes across multiple competitions and injuries. Both acknowledge Havertz had an exceptionally poor performance with minimal quality touches outside his penalty kick. They also discuss Victor Jokeres' anonymous display, noting he made little impact despite scoring one goal and appears to lack trust from his teammates in build-up play.
The midfield performance receives criticism for lateral passing and lack of penetration, with discussions of the "horseshoe of doom" (or "protractor of doom") formation where Arsenal recycled possession without creating meaningful chances. The hosts note that Martin Ødegaard's introduction at half-time changed this dynamic with more incisive passing. Lewis Skelly's reluctance to shoot when positioned well is highlighted as an area where younger players need to show more self-belief.
A significant portion covers Max Dowman's red card for a perceived kick-out against a Fleetwood player. The hosts debate the decision, with most agreeing it was harsh—more a petulant reaction than violent conduct. They note the Fleetwood players' overblown reactions and point out that Dowman now faces a three-game suspension at a time when Arsenal are light on wing options due to injuries to Saka and potential issues with Noni Mahiodieke.
The podcast addresses Mikel Arteta's public criticism of Dowman as he walked off the pitch, with James defending Arteta's reaction as a moment between manager and player within context of pre-match instructions about controlling emotions. Art notes that without understanding the exact words or private dynamics, it's difficult to judge harshly. They note Arteta was largely positive about the team publicly despite the poor performance.
On positives, they mention Kadak O'Neill's assist and note this serves as a learning experience for young players like Marley Salmon, who struggled against Fleetwood's striker due to physical development—suggesting a potential loan move in January could be beneficial. They credit Ben White for defending Dowman during the incident.
The hosts discuss potential silver linings: the competition elimination eliminates fixture congestion, provides rest for players, and Arsenal remain focused on Premier League and Champions League objectives. They compare this unfavorably to the Bradford City upset during a trophy drought but note the context is different with Arsenal recently winning the Premier League.
Looking forward, the discussion turns to Liverpool away at Anfield as the next fixture. They emphasize this as a chance for a statement performance and potential mental boost for the team. James predicts a very different Arsenal performance with first-team players returning. They discuss potential injury concerns around Noni Mahiodieke and suggest possible tactical adjustments if multiple wing players are unavailable, including a potential 4-4-2 diamond formation.
The podcast includes lighter segments featuring listener engagement, including a quiz about Arsenal players and personal Arsenal coincidence stories from listeners, plus a song selection from the hosts. The episode closes with hero/villain selections, with the traveling Arsenal fans receiving praise for their loyalty despite witnessing a poor performance.
About this episode
<p>In this episode, Ian Stone, James McNicholas and Art de Roché discuss Arsenal’s Carabao Cup exit on penalties at Fleetwood, Max Dowman’s red card and Arteta’s midfield experiments. They also preview the upcoming game against Liverpool, take on a Wenger-era quiz, and read some fan messages.</p><br /><p>Hosts: Ian Stone, Amy Lawrence, Adrian Clarke </p><br /><p>Producer: James Shaw </p><br /><p>Get in touch with video messages: [email protected]</p><hr /><p style="color: grey; font-size: 0.75em;"> Hosted on Acast. See <a href="https://acast.com/privacy" rel="noopener noreferrer" style="color: grey;" target="_blank">acast.com/privacy</a> for more information.</p>
Key Insights
- The hosts argue that Kai Havertz's poor performance was particularly disappointing because he had a promising start to the season but has been completely out of sync since the international break, with possible injury contributing to his decline.
- Art de Rocher contends that Mikel Arteta's team selection to rotate wings like Eze was justified given the three-games-in-six-days scheduling and injury management strategy, though Havertz's execution made the decision look poor in retrospect.
- The analysts observe that Victor Jokeres appears to lack trust from his teammates in possession, being used primarily as a decoy runner, and struggles to receive the ball in dangerous areas despite his goal in the match.
- James McNicholas argues that Arsenal's lack of urgency until the 85th minute, combined with one-dimensional passing patterns, suggests the team didn't fully respond to Arteta's half-time adjustments until desperation set in.
- The hosts debate that Max Dowman's red card was harsh and more reflective of petulant reaction than violent conduct, noting that the Fleetwood players' overblown reactions and the linesman's poor viewing angle influenced the referee's decision.
- Art de Rocher suggests that Marley Salmon's struggles at center-back are partly due to his incomplete physical development at 17, and that a loan move could have been beneficial for his development rather than learning at this level.
- The analysts contend that despite Arsenal's poor performance, the Carabao Cup elimination has a different significance than historical upsets like Bradford, because Arsenal are defending Premier League champions rather than in a trophy drought.
- James McNicholas argues that the Liverpool fixture represents a crucial opportunity for Arsenal to make a statement performance and potentially build momentum, with full first-team availability offering a stark contrast to the Fleetwood setup.
Topics
Transcript
Hey, we're Nick and Jack, hosts of The Best One Yet. Behind every episode, there's research, emails, spreadsheets, and our shared Google Doc, the Headline Hammer. With Google Workspace with Gemini, Google's AI is built right into the premium versions of tools we already use, like Gmail, Docs, and Sheets. No new tools or extra logins, just personalized AI for the way we work. That means less time on the work, around the work, and more time finding the stories worth talking about. Get AI tools for work. Upgrade to Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. That's goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bullspend,…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Handbrake Off: The Athletic FC's Arsenal show
Is this the best Arsenal team of the Premier League era?
Ian Stone, Amy Lawrence, and James McNicholas discuss Arsenal's exceptional start to the Premier League season (9 wins out of 10, 5 goals conceded), analyzing their defensive excellence and attacking limitations while exploring how Mikel Arteta maintains competitive edge through controlled intensity and player development like Noni Madueke's recent breakthrough.
Is Martin Odegaard already an Arsenal legend?
In this Handbrake Off podcast episode, hosts Ian Stone, Art de Roche, and Amy Lawrence analyze Arsenal's 2-0 victory over Slavia Prague in the Champions League, discussing the team's inconsistent performance across two halves, celebrating Victor Jokeres and Noni Madueke's improving form, and reflecting on Martin Odegaard's journey to 250 Arsenal appearances as he rediscovers his best form.
What does a win at Anfield mean for this Arsenal team?
Arsenal's 1-0 victory at Anfield is analyzed as a historic defensive masterclass, with the team breaking a 14-year winless streak at Liverpool through tactical discipline and collective commitment rather than brilliant attacking football. The hosts discuss standout performances from Declan Rice, Kai Havertz, and the defensive unit, while reflecting on how the prior Fleetwood loss may have galvanized the squad.
Arsenal dismantle Everton & Gabriel and White reach 200 games
Arsenal dominated Everton 2-0 with Gabriel and Esri Konca scoring, while Ben White and Gabriel both reached 200 appearances for the club. The hosts demonstrated superior teamwork and defensive coordination compared to Manchester United's struggling side, with Martin Ødegaard orchestrating play effectively throughout the match.
Will injuries derail Arsenal's season?
In this Arsenal podcast episode from The Athletic, hosts Ian Stone, Amy Lawrence, and Art de Rocher discuss Arsenal's 2-2 draw against Bayern Munich in the Champions League league phase, analyzing standout performances, tactical observations, and injury concerns that could impact the team's season.