InsightfulDiscussion

$30M Writer: Never write AI slop again

Greg Isenberg

Nicholas Cole, who earned $30M+ writing online, explains how to create valuable content in the AI era by building a personal language model of your unique ideas, personality, and perspective rather than generic commodity content. He argues that voice, original thinking, and consistent association through personality details create sustainable competitive advantage, while AI should be used to repeat and remix existing ideas, not generate net new thinking.

Summary

Nicholas Cole distinguishes between commodity content (generic information anyone could write), personality content (ideas tied to a specific person's experiences and perspective), and original content (truly novel thinking developed over years of crystallized thought). He argues that language is open-source—no one owns words or common phrases—so ownership really means association and credibility. Most people's content gets ignored in the AI era because it's indistinguishable commodity content that AI can generate infinitely.

Cole explains that SaaS and products have moats when they embody a point of view that requires founders to continuously innovate and think. Without a point of view, competing products are always one step behind. Similarly, writers need distinctive perspectives to compete with AI-generated commodity content. He discusses how to build a "digital brain" or personal language model—a library of your stories, opinions, lessons, and viewpoints that becomes your unmade data set, the information AI cannot access without you articulating it.

The core strategy involves three content types: (1) commodity content—basic ideas you agree or disagree with that establish your worldview and which AI can then repeat for you; (2) personality content—personal details, stories, and experiences that make you unique and resonate with audiences; and (3) original content—genuinely new thinking developed after years of deep work in a topic. Cole emphasizes that most people should focus on personality content—sharing formative experiences, mistakes, and perspectives—rather than seeking to create original thinking immediately.

Cole advocates for writers doing the thinking and humans doing the writing, while robots handle repetition and remixing. He describes his ghostwriting experience where he learned that voice is not mysterious—it's a bundle of intentional choices about word selection, sentence length, and structure. Most writing (80%) is commodity language with small subjective elements. He shares how adding just two sentences to a piece changed a client's perception of whether it sounded like them.

On the timely versus timeless spectrum, he argues that content should be evaluated for its short-term and long-term value. A viral meme might capture 24 hours of attention but zero long-term value, while a crystallized essay works for years. He proposes that companies should hire thoughtful writers and journalists to build high-quality content libraries that feed their entire marketing infrastructure, treating writing as valuable company data equivalent to customer data or transaction data. He positions the company brain as a sustainable competitive moat.

Key Insights

  • Cole argues that what people perceive as 'AI slop' is actually commodity content—groupings of words that are not attributable to any individual person. Language is open-source, no one owns individual words or most word combinations, so AI slop and commodity content are fundamentally the same thing.
  • Cole claims that ownership in writing and ideas is really just association—people associate ideas with specific people through volume of writing about that topic, personality details, or specific phrasings they've heard repeatedly. Gary Vaynerchuk's repeated references to buying the New York Jets is a personality detail that millions associate with him despite being unrelated to his core business.
  • Cole states that high-personality content often outperforms highly credible commodity content because audiences value familiarity with the person, their experiences, and their perspective more than pure expertise or credentials. A personal finance expert who shares her story as a single mother often outperforms a multi-billionaire expert sharing generic advice.
  • Cole argues that voice in writing is not an intangible quality but rather a bundle of intentional choices—specific word selection, sentence length, and structure—that can be learned and modified. When ghostwriting, he often used the same authoritative voice across 300+ different clients, and they all felt it sounded like them because voice comprises a small minority component of writing.
  • Cole proposes that companies should hire serious writers and journalists to think deeply about their industry and build long-form content libraries that feed their entire marketing infrastructure, treating the writer's crystallized thinking as valuable data equivalent to customer or transaction data—establishing the company brain as a sustainable competitive moat.

Topics

AI and content creationCommodity vs. personality vs. original contentPersonal brand and digital brain/personal language modelVoice and writing styleSaaS competitive advantage through point of viewTimely versus timeless contentLanguage as open-source systemAssociation and ownershipGhostwriting and content librariesCompany brain as data asset

Transcript

[0:00] Nicholas Coles made over 30 million dollars writing on the internet. So when he talks about content, I listen. And this episode honestly felt less like an interview and more like just a free masterclass. He breaks down why most people's content gets ignored in the AI era, why AI is making generic writing worthless, and how to build what he calls a digital brain. A library of your stories and your opinions and your lessons and ideas that gets you customers 24-7, that builds [0:30] you trust and gives AI something real to work with. If you write online, you sell online, or you want ideas to compound, this is honestly worth thousands of dollars, but it's free…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Greg Isenberg

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.