The Spiritual Cure for Anxiety, Depression & Unshakable Faith with Rabbi David Yisrael Kalmus
Rabbi David Yisrael Kalmus discusses his journey from severe treatment-resistant depression through ECT therapy to spiritual recovery via Rabbi Nachman's teachings, emphasizing that faith (emunah), daily prayer (hitbodedut), and speech are the primary tools for mental and spiritual healing rather than medical interventions alone.
Summary
Rabbi Kalmus shares an extensive personal testimony of struggling with depression and anxiety since age 10, compounded by growing up secular without faith. Despite trying psychiatric medications, diets, workouts, TMS, and ultimately electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)—which has an 80% success rate for treatment-resistant depression—he remained among the 20% for whom it failed and lost years of memory as a result. This crisis led him to Rabbi Nachman's teachings, particularly the concept that some illnesses are "faithful illnesses" bound by faith rather than nature, requiring emunah rather than medicine. He made a covenant to spend an hour daily in hitbodedut (intimate prayer with God in one's native language) without trying to fix anything himself, believing God would provide healing. Twelve years later, he credits this practice with his recovery and has since established the first English-speaking Breslov yeshiva in Israel. The conversation explores Rabbi Nachman's core teachings: that challenges exist to draw people toward prayer and connection with God; that speech liberates the Shekhinah (divine presence) trapped within; that emunah (faith/patience) is the soil in which all efforts must grow; and that problems contain their own solutions when reframed through a spiritual lens. Kalmus and co-host Gedaliah emphasize that inspiration without action is worthless, that desire must match the greatness of what one seeks, that avoiding pain creates more pain, and that the yeshiva's distinctiveness lies in character transformation rather than mere intellectual study. They discuss practical applications including self-esteem, boundaries, rejection sensitivity, and the importance of extending one's perspective beyond immediate circumstances. The discussion culminates with a Holocaust story illustrating how holding onto a tzaddik's (righteous person's) teachings provides spiritual support through impossible situations.
About this episode
<p>Visit gedale-fenster.com</p><p><br /></p><p>Contact Rabbi David</p><p>[email protected]</p><p>tzionbreslov.com</p><p>thebreslovyeshiva.com</p>
Key Insights
- Kalmus argues that entering a relationship with God paradoxically intensifies internal struggles as suppressed issues surface, contrary to the expectation that faith provides immediate relief.
- The speaker claims that certain illnesses are 'faithful illnesses' bound by faith rather than nature, meaning medical intervention cannot cure them and only emunah (faith) can provide healing.
- Kalmus contends that even ECT, which has an 80% success rate for treatment-resistant depression, failed in his case because his illness required spiritual rather than neurological treatment.
- The speaker argues that people fail to pursue spiritual practices not because of lack of time or resources, but because they have not increased the value of those practices to match their actual importance.
- Kalmus claims that loneliness and rejection sensitivity stem from seeking external approval rather than self-approval, and that connecting to God's life force eliminates dependence on others' validation.
- The speaker asserts that avoiding or medicating pain prevents the development of emunah and actually creates more suffering, as pain is necessary for spiritual vessel-building.
- Kalmus maintains that speech is the Shekhinah (divine presence) made manifest, and that suppressing speech keeps the divine trapped, which is why Rabbi Nachman emphasizes hitbodedut as the primary spiritual tool.
- The speaker argues that all challenges in life serve a single purpose: to propel a person toward prayer and relationship with God, making the reframing of suffering as purposeful the key therapeutic intervention.
Topics
Transcript
All right, welcome to today's class. Today's class is sponsored by Yitai Yehudah B'mor Ha'Gitel, Ritual Raw Matchmaking. Today's class is also in success. Yerach Shemaim, Avgad Yom Ha'Nesheva, Eman Ha'Nesheva, Shefer Ha'Nesheva, Reina Magvartov Ha'Vasha, and Ema Ben-Esheva. Today's class is sponsored by Ritual Raw Matchmaking, and Yitai Yehudah B'mor Ha'Gitel. Welcome, welcome Rabbi, welcome to the podcast. The Rabbi, Rabbi Kamenetz is the head of the yeshiva for first american-speaking yeshiva in israel for breslau for breslau that's right you put you put it on the map put it on the map thank god and that'd be helped us do it and the rabbi is speak a little bit about your some of your challenges you've had you've…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Gedale Fenster - Podcast
Don’t ask for a bailout. Ask for the right advice
A spiritual teaching on Hoshana Rabbah and Simchas Torah emphasizing that instead of asking God for direct salvation (bailouts), one should ask for the right advice and strategy to achieve goals through a journey of micro-steps. The speaker argues that faith, gratitude, and continuous forward momentum are essential to spiritual growth and receiving divine help.
10 Lessons I Received From Rabbi Nachman
A spiritual teaching class on Rabbi Nachman's ten core lessons for achieving higher consciousness and personal transformation. The speaker emphasizes that all life challenges are tests designed to elevate us, that gratitude and belief are essential tools for solving problems, and that maintaining constant spiritual desire while accepting divine will is the path to meaningful change.
10 Lessons I Received From Rabbi Nachman
A spiritual teacher presents ten core lessons from Rabbi Nachman's teachings, emphasizing that life's difficulties are tests designed to elevate consciousness, that gratitude and desire are transformative forces, and that maintaining heat, speech, and joy in spiritual practice are essential for drawing divine light into one's life.
Rabbi Nachman on manifestation
A class on Rabbi Nachman's teachings about manifestation emphasizing that focused, detailed thought without sensory distraction can bring about desired outcomes, and that struggles and acceptance of God's will are essential for spiritual growth and receiving blessings.
Your lack is God's lack and how to rectify it
A spiritual teaching on overcoming lack by understanding that God continuously offers blessings, but personal shadows and traumas block receiving them. The speaker emphasizes rejoicing in difficulties, taking accountability for blockages, and developing proper relationships with desires and material goods to rectify lack in all areas of life.