Labor Market Cracks, Wild Fed Credibility Data and Semis Running Out of Pie | Last Call
This episode of Last Call examines market dynamics across multiple sectors, focusing on semiconductor supply constraints, Fed credibility narratives, labor market composition, and refinery economics. Hosts discuss how earnings growth expectations exceed available GDP growth, creating competitive pressure in tech and semis, while highlighting risks in volatility structures and inflation drivers often overlooked by policymakers.
Summary
The episode opens with discussion of SpaceX's recent IPO, analyzing how index flows and market positioning drove initial volatility rather than fundamental valuation. Hosts note that sophisticated market participants priced in the NASDAQ index addition before it occurred, demonstrating multi-layered positioning strategies.
Andy Constant introduces his "Fab Five Freddy" thesis, arguing that semiconductor fabrication equipment manufacturers (ASML, Applied Materials, KLA, Lam Research, Tokyo Electron) are capturing disproportionate value in the AI infrastructure build-out. His core argument centers on a "pie" concept: while nominal GDP grows, too many stocks expect massive earnings growth without enough economic growth to support all of them. The real winners are fabs and equipment makers supplying the hyperscalers, while hyperscalers and chip companies spend heavily without proportional profits.
Ben Hunt presents narrative analysis showing the Fed's credibility has dramatically reversed from all-time lows (June 2023) to positive territory currently. The "losing credibility" narrative that dominated during Trump's calls for Powell's removal has quieted, while "gaining credibility" narratives have strengthened, surprising Hunt given his personal skepticism of recent Fed communications. He connects this to gold's weakness and dollar strength, explaining gold as "one divided by trust" — as Fed credibility rises, gold prices fall.
Brent Kachuba analyzes options market positioning through his core 1M correlation metric, warning that when it drops below 8, market volatility spasms occur. He documents that 80% of QQQ options volume concentrates in 5-days-to-expiration or less, indicating aggressive short-term positioning rather than conviction in long-term AI growth narratives. He predicts coordinated volatility resets across disparate volatility regimes as they synchronize. For SpaceX specifically, he describes initial gamma squeeze dynamics that normalized as index addition approached.
Eric Pacman provides granular labor market analysis revealing that job growth concentrates in low-wage positions: 4.3 million home health aides earning $35,000 annually, restaurant workers, and leisure/hospitality roles, driven by baby boomer demographics. Meanwhile, professional services employment trends downward, suggesting high-wage job displacement. He then pivots to crack spreads — the refiner margin between crude input and fuel output — currently at $62 per barrel versus normal $15-20 levels. This elevated spread reflects supply chain disruption from the Strait of Hormuz closure and means gas and diesel prices disconnect from oil prices, with inflation consequences for consumers and transportation costs that policymakers underestimate.
Hosts conclude by discussing how competitive dynamics shift in maturing AI cycles, using World Cup analogies about "parking the bus" defensive strategies. They argue efficiency improvements and innovation acceleration will intensify as companies optimize high-cost infrastructure spending, suggesting the market enters a phase where competitive outcomes become more differentiated rather than "everything up together."
Key Insights
- Andy Constant argues that future earnings growth expectations are oversupscribed — too many stocks expect massive growth but there isn't enough pie (nominal GDP growth) for all to succeed, forcing competition that transfers value to equipment suppliers rather than end users.
- Ben Hunt documents that Fed credibility narratives reversed from historic lows in June 2023 (when Trump called for Powell's removal) to currently positive territory, directly correlating with Powell's continued tenure and Trump not attacking the Fed, which influences gold weakness.
- Brent Kachuba identifies that over 80% of QQQ options volume concentrates in 5-days-to-expiration expirations, suggesting this is not a conviction bet on long-term AI value but rather short-term speculative positioning prone to volatility resets.
- Eric Pacman reveals that US job growth concentrates in low-wage positions like home health aides ($35,000/year) due to demographics, while professional services decline, meaning the labor market appears strong by headcount but lacks wealth-creation capacity.
- Eric Pacman explains that crack spreads (refiner margins) are at $62 per barrel versus normal $15-20, meaning gas and diesel prices now decouple from oil prices due to Strait of Hormuz supply disruptions, creating inflation pressures through transportation costs that policymakers overlook.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] that future earnings growth is overs subscribed. There's too many people that too many stocks that expect massive earnings growth and there's just not enough pie for all of them to be successful. This is a wild chart, right? The losing credibility narrative has gone away from this time a year ago. and the gaining credibility narrative, the dark blue on this on this map, it's now [0:32] positive. >> The issue is the rate of change is unsustainable, right? Like how how much longer can you keep going up in the cues at 2% per day, right? That that is not sustainable. Uh it all gets priced in at some point. >> The crack spread does not lie.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Excess Returns
He Reverse-Engineered Why Amazon Won | Ritavan on Why the Moat Is the Wrong Test
Ritavan discusses the concept of a 'system gambit,' focusing on how companies can create defensible business strategies through compound systems rather than relying on traditional moats. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding the underlying systems of businesses to identify unique opportunities for growth, especially in the context of AI adoption.
Expensive Market. Record Issuance. Can the Story Still Hold It Up? | 6 Things We Learned This Week
The Excess Returns weekly podcast breaks down lessons from interviews with Aswath Damodaran, Andy Constan, and Tobias Carlisle on SpaceX's valuation, IPO dynamics, market valuations, capital expenditure trends, and emerging signs of a potential reversal from large-cap growth to small-cap and value stocks.
The $2 Trillion Trapdoor | Tobias Carlisle on SpaceX, the AI Buildout, and the Rotation No One Sees
Tobias Carlisle discusses current market valuations, the impact of AI on business profitability, and the construction of his investment portfolios in the context of a potentially value-oriented market shift. He emphasizes the importance of recognizing market cycles and reversion to mean in investment strategies.
The Trillion Dollar Gap | Aswath Damodaran on SpaceX, AI and the Big Market Delusion
Aswath Damodaran discusses the valuation challenges and market narratives surrounding SpaceX, particularly in the context of AI's impact and the evolving nature of value investing. He emphasizes the importance of not conflating strong company narratives with solid investment fundamentals.
The $700 Billion Shift | Andy Constan on What Happens When Buybacks Turn into Issuance
Andy Constan discusses the massive shift from stock buybacks to equity issuance driven by AI capex spending, analyzes the SpaceX IPO as a model of successful capital markets function, and argues that AI's value depends on whether it creates disinflationary productivity growth or merely displaces workers, with the consumer still supported by asset sales and wealth effects.