Why the Past Feels Slower Than It Was - Ada Palmer
Ada Palmer argues that the popular video game Civilization perpetuates a false narrative that time moved slower in the past, showing antiquity turns as 50 years versus modern turns as 1 year. She contends this misconception is also found in textbooks, but historians studying any specific decade find it moved as fast as the present.
Summary
Ada Palmer discusses her research on the video game Civilization (Civ) and its impact on historical perception. She notes that Civ is the world's number one teacher of history, having shipped 70 million copies, and reaches a massive audience since 65% of people with access to technology play video games. The game structures time progression to suggest that historical periods moved at different speeds - with turns representing 50 years in antiquity, 25 years in medieval times, 10 years during the industrial revolution, and just 1 year in modernity. This design implies that as much change happens in one modern year as happened in 50 ancient years. Palmer identifies this as a fundamental misrepresentation that extends beyond gaming into educational materials like textbooks. She challenges this narrative by pointing to historical scholarship, noting that whenever historians examine any specific decade from any time period and location, that period feels as dynamic and fast-moving as our contemporary era. This suggests that the perception of accelerating historical time is a modern bias rather than an accurate reflection of how change actually occurred in different eras.
Key Insights
- Palmer claims that the video game Civ is the number one teacher of history in the world, having shipped 70 million copies
- Palmer states that 65% of people on Earth who have technology play video games, giving games massive educational influence
- Palmer argues that Civ teaches a false progression where antiquity turns represent 50 years while modern turns represent just 1 year
- Palmer contends that textbooks perpetuate the same lie that time moved slower in the past
- Palmer observes that historians studying any specific decade from any era find it feels as fast-moving as the present
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access