Why Censorship Always Misses What Actually Matters - Ada Palmer
Ada Palmer, a historian of censorship, explains how censors throughout history consistently misidentify threats, focusing on minor issues while ignoring truly revolutionary ideas. She uses the French Enlightenment as an example, where the Inquisition obsessed over Jansenist religious treatises while largely ignoring Voltaire and the Encyclopedia.
Summary
Ada Palmer presents a historical analysis of how censorship efforts systematically fail to target the most significant threats to established order. Using the French Enlightenment period as her primary example, she illustrates how the Inquisition was far more concerned with Jansenism—a Calvinist-influenced version of Catholicism focused on theological debates about the Trinity—than with genuinely revolutionary works by Voltaire, Rousseau, and materialist atheist philosophers whose ideas were spreading across Europe. Palmer describes a specific incident from Matis's book where authorities raided a clandestine bookshop and were willing to overlook Voltaire's works and the banned Encyclopedia, which would 'revolutionize all thought in Europe,' while aggressively pursuing Jansenist treatises. The absurdity of their priorities is highlighted in an anecdote about a ceremonial book burning where officials marched the Encyclopedia to the fire but, upon encountering Jansenist texts about the Trinity, chose to burn those instead because they preferred to preserve the Encyclopedia. Palmer presents this as a universal pattern in censorship throughout history.
Key Insights
- Palmer argues that censors throughout history are consistently wrong about what they should be worried about censoring from our modern perspective
- Palmer describes how the Inquisition was more worried about Jansenist treatises about the Trinity than about Voltaire and materialist atheist ideas spreading across Europe
- Palmer explains that authorities raiding clandestine bookshops would overlook Voltaire's works and the Encyclopedia while aggressively pursuing Jansenist religious treatises
- Palmer recounts how officials chose to burn Jansenist texts about the Trinity instead of the Encyclopedia during a ceremonial burning because they actually loved the Encyclopedia
- Palmer states this pattern of misidentifying censorship priorities is a universal truth throughout history
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] I study the history of censorship. They're always wrong from our perspective about what they should be worried about censoring. So here we are in the French enlightenment. Voltater and Rouso and the Marquita Assad and Latreul articulations of materialist atheism are flying around Europe. And what is the Inquisition worried about? It's worried about Jansenist treatises about the nature of the Trinity. Jansenism is sort of like a Calvinist version of Catholicism. And they are so much more worried about Jansenism than they are about Voltater. That very uh [0:32] chapter in Matis's book I mentioned where they're raiding the clandestine bookshop and they're like Voltater fine. The band Cyclopedi which is going to revolutionize all thought in…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Dwarkesh Patel
China's Belt and Road Problem - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine argues that China's Belt and Road Initiative is strategically flawed, citing the economic and security superiority of maritime shipping over land-based routes and China's vulnerability to naval blockade in wartime due to its geographical position surrounded by shallow seas and islands.
Einstein's happiest thought: General Relativity from scratch – Adam Brown
Adam Brown explains Einstein's general relativity from first principles, starting with the equivalence principle and how gravity curves spacetime. He demonstrates why black holes exist as inevitable consequences of general relativity and discusses how falling into a black hole feels different depending on your reference frame.
The Real Effects of the Six Day War - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine explains how Egypt's closure of the Suez Canal during the Six Day War had unexpected strategic consequences that reshaped global shipping. The blockade forced the development of much larger cargo ships that could not fit through the canal, fundamentally altering maritime economics in ways that persisted long after the canal reopened.
The Dutch-American who saw America's blind spot clearly - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine discusses Nicholas Spikeman, a Dutch-American geopolitical thinker who warned in 1943 that control of Eurasia could determine global dominance. Spikeman critiqued American statesmen for consistently miscalculating outcomes and failing to develop effective national security strategies, despite the US occupying an advantageous geographic position.
How Geography Shapes Empire - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine traces the origins of maritime empires back to Athens, contrasting sea-based empires like Rome with land-based empires like Russia and China. She illustrates how geographical terminology reflects fundamentally different imperial orientations: Mediterranean empires centered on the sea as a connecting medium, while Chinese civilization emphasized land-based central authority.