Pamphlets, Newspapers, and the Birth of the Magazine — Ada Palmer
Ada Palmer presents historical examples of early print media, including pamphlets, newspapers, and the first magazine, while also examining the physical materials used in early printing and writing. She traces the evolution from sensationalist pamphlets to The Gentleman's Magazine, which pioneered fact-checking by comparing contradicting newspaper accounts.
Summary
Ada Palmer opens by describing pamphlets as cheap, ephemeral printed media that took only two to four days to produce. These short, hand-stitched publications were sold in bulk around towns and to traveling news writers, covering topics ranging from siege reports to royal wedding fashion. She highlights their often sensationalist nature with an example title involving murder, seduction, and cannibalism, noting that pamphlets ranged from outright nonsense to real news, with most being a combination of both.
Palmer then explains the physical properties of early paper, noting that the characteristic blue-gray color of cheap paper covers came from the material itself — paper made from beaten rags that, when unbleached, took on the average color of human clothing. She then transitions to discussing The Gentleman's Magazine, a publication that arose in response to a key problem with the early newspaper era: newspapers frequently contradicted each other, leaving readers uncertain about the truth. The Gentleman's Magazine addressed this by publishing weekly roundups that compiled what various newspapers said about the same events, analyzed contradictions, and assessed which accounts were accurate. Palmer credits it as the first magazine and the origin of the word 'magazine' in this media context.
The talk concludes with a brief examination of historical writing materials. Palmer notes that papyrus, while cheap, is brittle and better suited to scrolls than folded formats because the folded edge cracks easily. She then shows attendees a 17th-century letter written in indecipherable handwriting on cheap parchment, explaining how one can identify which side of the animal skin was the outside versus the inside. She also presents an example of higher-quality parchment and notes that scribes would write around holes in parchment sheets rather than discard them, reflecting how valuable these materials were.
Key Insights
- Palmer argues that pamphlets were not purely factual or fictional — most were combinations of real news and nonsense, and they circulated widely by being sold to traveling news writers moving between cities.
- Palmer explains that the characteristic blue-gray color of cheap pamphlet covers came directly from the papermaking process: unbleached rags beaten into pulp produced the average color of human clothing.
- Palmer claims that The Gentleman's Magazine was created specifically in response to the problem of newspapers contradicting each other, functioning as a weekly media roundup that analyzed which accounts were accurate — essentially the first fact-checking publication.
- Palmer states that The Gentleman's Magazine invented the word 'magazine' as used in the context of periodical publications.
- Palmer notes that scribes wrote around holes in parchment rather than discarding the sheet, illustrating how valuable writing materials were — and that cheap parchment visibly shows which side was the outside versus inside of the animal skin.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] This is a pamphlet. Naked pages, short text, handstitched together. It would take two or four days to print a pamphlet like that. It's cheap. It's ephemeral. You print a thousand of them. You sell a bunch around the town. You sell a bunch to news writers who are going to and from other cities. And it might be, you know, a report of a siege. It might be here's what the people were wearing at the royal wedding. My favorite ever t title of a pamphlet was the scandalous tale of a doctor from Padua and how he seduced his maid, [0:30] murdered his wife, murdered the maid, cut out her heart and ate it, and how he…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Dwarkesh Patel
China's Belt and Road Problem - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine argues that China's Belt and Road Initiative is strategically flawed, citing the economic and security superiority of maritime shipping over land-based routes and China's vulnerability to naval blockade in wartime due to its geographical position surrounded by shallow seas and islands.
Einstein's happiest thought: General Relativity from scratch – Adam Brown
Adam Brown explains Einstein's general relativity from first principles, starting with the equivalence principle and how gravity curves spacetime. He demonstrates why black holes exist as inevitable consequences of general relativity and discusses how falling into a black hole feels different depending on your reference frame.
The Real Effects of the Six Day War - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine explains how Egypt's closure of the Suez Canal during the Six Day War had unexpected strategic consequences that reshaped global shipping. The blockade forced the development of much larger cargo ships that could not fit through the canal, fundamentally altering maritime economics in ways that persisted long after the canal reopened.
The Dutch-American who saw America's blind spot clearly - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine discusses Nicholas Spikeman, a Dutch-American geopolitical thinker who warned in 1943 that control of Eurasia could determine global dominance. Spikeman critiqued American statesmen for consistently miscalculating outcomes and failing to develop effective national security strategies, despite the US occupying an advantageous geographic position.
How Geography Shapes Empire - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine traces the origins of maritime empires back to Athens, contrasting sea-based empires like Rome with land-based empires like Russia and China. She illustrates how geographical terminology reflects fundamentally different imperial orientations: Mediterranean empires centered on the sea as a connecting medium, while Chinese civilization emphasized land-based central authority.