History Was Never Slow - Ada Palmer
Ada Palmer argues that history has always moved quickly and people have always experienced rapid change, but modern history education creates a false perception of past stagnation by compressing large time periods and focusing only on technologies we still value today.
Summary
Palmer challenges the common perception that historical change was slow compared to modern times. She argues that this misconception stems from how history is taught in schools, where educators attempt to cover vast time periods quickly, creating an illusion of stagnation during earlier eras. In reality, people throughout history experienced their times as periods of rapid change - for example, people in the 1320s felt nostalgic for the 1300s, just as we feel nostalgic for recent decades. Palmer attributes this misunderstanding to 19th-century historians who grouped events together to make modernity appear uniquely fast-paced and special. Regarding technological change, she argues that while we acknowledge past eras weren't technologically advancing as rapidly as today, they were actually experiencing constant innovation. The difference is that we no longer value or notice many historical technological advances, taking inventions like backed chairs, scissors, and metallurgical improvements for granted, even though these represented significant technological leaps for people of their time.
Key Insights
- When teaching history, avoid compressing large time periods as this creates false impressions of stagnation - instead focus on how each decade brought meaningful changes that people of the time experienced as rapid
- Recognize that our evaluation of past technological progress is biased by present-day values - innovations we take for granted (chairs with backs, scissors, metallurgy) were revolutionary advances that drove rapid change in their time
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access