When the Islamic School Gets under the Mercy of the Parents - Dr Zakir Naik
Dr. Zakir Naik recounts a visit to one of South Africa's best Islamic schools, where the principal described a dynamic in which parents blackmail the school with threats of withdrawal if standards are too strict. He contrasts this with his own institution's approach, where the school asserts authority over parents in the name of Islamic principles.
Summary
In this short clip, Dr. Zakir Naik shares an anecdote from a visit to South Africa, where he visited what was described as one of the best Islamic schools in the region approximately 60 years prior. The principal of that school confided in him that the institution was effectively 'at the mercy of the parents,' meaning that despite offering fees half the price of other private schools, the school felt unable to enforce strict Islamic standards without risking losing students.
The principal described a specific incident where female students in the eighth and ninth grade were found at a hotel one evening wearing revealing clothing and dancing — behavior the school considered unacceptable. When parents were confronted, rather than supporting the school's position, they threatened to withdraw their children and enroll them in government or non-Islamic schools if the school became too strict.
Dr. Naik concludes by contrasting this situation with his own school's philosophy, stating that in his institution, it is the school that holds leverage over the parents — a dynamic he frames as being done for the sake of Allah. The clip highlights a broader tension between maintaining Islamic educational standards and the commercial or social pressures that Islamic schools face when parents prioritize convenience or leniency over religious discipline.
Key Insights
- Dr. Zakir Naik recounts that the principal of one of South Africa's best Islamic schools described the institution as being 'at the mercy of the parents,' unable to enforce standards without risking enrollment loss.
- The principal told Dr. Naik that despite charging fees half those of other private schools, parents still used the threat of withdrawal as leverage against the school's attempts to enforce discipline.
- The principal cited a specific incident where female students in grades eight and nine were found at a hotel wearing mini skirts and shorts and dancing, which the school considered a serious breach of Islamic conduct.
- Dr. Naik describes how parents responded to disciplinary concerns not with support, but with threats to remove their children from the Islamic school in favor of government or 'white' schools.
- Dr. Naik contrasts the South African school's predicament with his own institution's approach, claiming that in his school it is the school that 'blackmails' the parents — framing this assertive stance as being done for the sake of Allah.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access