InsightfulDiscussion

Benn Jordan thinks the surveillance problem is much bigger than Flock

Decoder with Nilay Patel1h 2m

Ben Jordan, a musician and investigative journalist, discusses his work exposing security vulnerabilities in Flock's automatic license plate reader system and the broader surveillance infrastructure. He explains how a startup's defensive PR strategy made it a target while larger contractors quietly built similar networks, and argues that the real problem lies in government oversight failures rather than any single company.

Summary

Ben Jordan describes his evolution from musician and hacker to investigative journalist focused on Flock cameras and ALPR (Automatic License Plate Reader) technology. He discovered he lived in Atlanta, which has the highest density of Flock cameras per square mile, and began investigating their security vulnerabilities and surveillance capabilities. Unlike traditional ALPR systems mounted on police cars requiring warrants through the National Crime Information Center, Flock created a private nationwide network allowing police departments across the country to search 30 days of location data on any vehicle without warrants, fundamentally changing surveillance scope.

Jordan identified multiple security failures: lack of multi-factor authentication, open administrative interfaces accessible from the internet, hardware vulnerabilities allowing Wi-Fi access point creation, and plain text credentials. He found Flock credentials being sold on the dark web by Russian vendors. When he initially reported these findings, Flock dismissed him as a YouTuber performing "magic tricks," but eventually took the security issues seriously after media coverage.

Crucially, Jordan emphasizes that Flock became a "low-hanging fruit" primarily because of its defensive PR strategy and CEO personality, while competitors like Axon and Motorola quietly built similar private networks without the same public backlash. He argues the real problem is government failure to implement security protocols, warrant requirements, or audit processes before deploying this technology.

Jordan testified before the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism, chaired by Republican Senator Josh Hawley, focusing on legislative responsibility rather than attacking Flock specifically. He notes the bipartisan pushback against both Flock and data centers represents people waking up to surveillance infrastructure they never voted on and can't opt out of. Unlike digital services where people can theoretically choose alternatives, property tax dollars fund surveillance systems without consent.

He discusses how surveillance doesn't actually solve crime effectively. Crime relocation is real—putting cameras in one area moves crime elsewhere rather than preventing it. Clearance rates for non-violent offenses don't address root causes like poverty or addiction, instead feeding more people into the justice system. He argues effective solutions require immutable audit logs, security audits, opt-out mechanisms at the DMV, warrant requirements, and transparency in government decision-making.

Jordan now works with Flock directly, reporting vulnerabilities responsibly rather than publicly. He views this as offering an olive branch to enable actual solutions, rejecting the "throw poop" approach that prevents remediation. He's frustrated that while Flock executives expressed willingness to accept guardrails, legislators haven't provided clear frameworks. He warns that if surveillance companies are destroyed without proper guardrails in place, Palantir and other contractors will simply replace them with more sophisticated systems.

On YouTube and social media, he emphasizes maintaining journalistic ethics and nuance even when sensational approaches would generate more views. He deliberately didn't leak Flock Forward attendee information he discovered through app decompilation, reasoning that undermining privacy standards he advocates for would be hypocritical. He believes audiences increasingly value trustworthiness over engagement-baiting, and that detailed, nuanced research builds loyal audiences and encourages viewers to explore and improve upon his work.

About this episode

Today, I’m talking with Benn Jordan, musician, YouTuber, researcher, and investigative journalist. In the last couple of years, Benn has become a high-profile face in the creator and media spaces for his work investigating Flock Safety, the maker of automatic license plate readers and the software that powers them.  Benn recently testified in front of Congress at a hearing dedicated to Flock and other ALPR systems. So of course I wanted to dig into all of that with Benn, not just because of his role as a Flock critic, but because he’s also become in some ways the face of a new front in the broader debate about surveillance and privacy.  Links:  Benn Jordan testifies in front of Senate | Benn Jordan (YouTube) Flock values their privacy. Oh well | Benn Jordan (YouTube) We Hacked Flock Safety Cameras in under 30 Seconds | Benn Jordan (YouTube) Lawmakers introduce multiple laws to curb Flock | 404 Media The fight over Flock and other ALPRs | The Verge Sanders, AOC, Merkley propose bill to ban Flock cameras | Politico Cities terminate Flock contracts at record pace in August | Ars Technica Flock to cut several hundred jobs amid backlash | Reuters Subscribe to The Verge to access the ad-free version of Decoder! Credits: Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Decoder’s producers are Greg Ott, Kate Cox, and Nick Statt. This episode was edited by Ursa Wright. Our editorial director is Kevin McShane.  The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Key Insights

  • Flock became controversial not because its technology was uniquely bad, but because the company was defensive, had a visible CEO personality, and repeatedly disputed security vulnerabilities—a PR strategy that backfired while competitors like Axon and Motorola quietly built equivalent networks without scrutiny.
  • The innovation Flock introduced wasn't the cameras themselves but a private nationwide database accessible without warrants, bypassing the National Crime Information Center's requirement for magistrate approval—a legal distinction that enabled mass surveillance circumventing existing Fourth Amendment protections.
  • Jordan argues the real problem is government negligence rather than corporate villainy: legislators failed to implement security protocols, audit processes, or warrant requirements before allowing cities to spend taxpayer money on surveillance infrastructure.
  • Unlike digital services where users can theoretically opt out by not using the product, surveillance funded through property taxes forces citizens to pay for systems they never voted on and cannot escape by leaving the area.
  • Increased surveillance doesn't reduce overall crime but relocates it to areas with less camera coverage, making crime prevention primarily a wealth-based phenomenon that protects affluent neighborhoods while pushing crime to lower-income areas.
  • Flock credentials being sold on the dark web by Russian vendors demonstrates that even if Flock improved its own security, the entire network's security depends on the weakest police department's password hygiene—a systemic vulnerability.
  • Jordan found open administrative interfaces on Flock cameras accessible from the internet where anyone could delete footage, watch recordings, modify files, and access plain text credentials, suggesting security was treated as an afterthought rather than foundational.
  • Warrant-less searches for non-violent crimes like shoplifting don't make society safer but feed people with poverty or addiction problems into the justice system instead of addressing root causes through public policy.
  • The bipartisan pushback against surveillance comes from different ideological concerns—Republicans remember COVID lockdowns and fear government tracking of dissent, while Democrats focus on civil liberties—but both recognize surveillance enables authoritarianism.
  • Jordan rejects both the "throw poop" approach of destruction and the "let companies self-regulate" approach, instead advocating for immutable audit logs, security audits, DMV-based opt-outs, and clear legislative guardrails that allow companies to operate transparently.
  • Working with Flock directly after criticizing it publicly allows Jordan to maintain journalistic integrity while pursuing actual solutions, refusing to leak breach data even when it would generate viral content, because maintaining ethical standards is necessary to advocate for privacy standards.
  • The conspiracy theory that phones listen to conversations is actually less efficient than the real threat: algorithms predict human behavior through transaction history, location data, and subtle patterns far more effectively than audio surveillance, making the actual threat scarier than imagined conspiracies.

Topics

ALPR technology and Flock's private surveillance networkSecurity vulnerabilities in surveillance infrastructureGovernment oversight failures in deployment of mass surveillanceBipartisan backlash against surveillance and data centersCompetitive advantage of low-profile contractors over startupsJournalism ethics and working with companies under investigationCrime prevention efficacy and crime relocation effectsImmutable audit logs and accountability mechanismsYouTube content strategy and nuance in digital mediaOpt-out mechanisms and citizen consent for surveillanceWarrant requirements and Fourth Amendment protections

Transcript

Support for the show comes from CrowdStrike. It's not a huge stretch to say that AI is the next major computing platform. Every platform shift changes the way we build software, and it changes security too. CrowdStrike is defining cybersecurity in the AI era with AI Detection and Response, or AIDR, a solution for seeing, monitoring, and securing AI across the enterprise. Learn more about how leading companies are turning to CrowdStrike to secure AI and secure their business at CrowdStrike.com slash decoder. Maybe that late-night ping is an urgent email from your CEO. Or maybe it's a deepfake targeting your business. Doppel is the AI-native social engineering defense platform fighting back against impersonation and manipulation. As attackers use AI…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Decoder with Nilay Patel

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.