What It Means to Be a “Real” Entrepreneur | Michael Rubin, Fanatics
Michael Rubin, founder and CEO of Fanatics, discusses what makes entrepreneurs "real," sharing his journey from near-bankruptcy at 16 to building a $14 billion revenue company. He emphasizes the importance of relationships, learning from failure, and maintaining authentic self-presentation while building a diversified sports entertainment platform across merchandise, sports betting, and collectibles.
Summary
Michael Rubin explains why he finds many billionaires boring despite their wealth, attributing their lack of interest to their unwillingness to be authentic and share their failures. He contrasts this with what people actually want to hear: entrepreneurial stories that include both successes and failures, self-deprecating humor, and genuine personality. Rubin exemplifies this by publicly discussing his use of weight-loss drugs, something he credits others with now openly discussing after he broke the silence.
Rubin identifies key advisors who influence his thinking, particularly Robert Kraft, with whom he discusses major business challenges. He emphasizes that Kraft's advice on staying calm during crises—sleeping on problems before reacting—has saved him from making destructive long-term business decisions. He also values relationships with figures like Jimmy Irvine and learns from successful entrepreneurs across industries.
On the nature of real entrepreneurship, Rubin argues it's something people are born with, characterized by genuine passion, addiction to the work, and inability to stop. He contrasts this with people who sell successful companies and become passive investors, noting they're "not an entrepreneur anymore" because the passion has left their blood. He plans to work until his heart stops beating.
Rubin's early business history began at age 12 with a ski tuning shop in his parents' basement, expanding to a retail location by age 14. At 16, overextending himself and arrogance during a year without snow nearly bankrupted him with $200,000 in bills against $80,000 in inventory. He hired a bankruptcy attorney, discovered he couldn't legally incur debt until age 18, settled debts for $35,000, then purchased bankrupt inventory for $13,000 (borrowed at $1,000/week interest). He repaid this within three weeks and grew the business to $150 million in revenue by age 21, making $10-15 million annually.
During the 2008-2009 financial crisis, Rubin nearly lost his company when his $250 million stock portfolio (used as collateral) dropped 90% to $25 million. Unable to access $50 million he'd previously borrowed against stock, he faced margin calls within hours of bankruptcy. He called a hedge fund manager approximately 100 times before the man finally agreed to return $5 million, saving Rubin from losing the company. Just over a year later, eBay purchased the company for $2.4 billion in March 2011.
Rubin emphasizes that relationships are everything, especially during crises. He notes that when business is good, relationships are easy; when things go wrong, relationships get tested. He cites examples like Phil Knight and Nike, where investors or bankers put themselves on the line during difficult periods, superseding standard business logic. For Rubin, these difficult periods have always been intellectually interesting and presented opportunities to build better businesses.
On authentic self-presentation, Rubin contrasts himself with many wealthy people who are protective and careful about their public image. He believes transparency about struggles and failures makes people more interesting and relatable. He references studying athletes to understand what makes them successful, noting that killer instinct separates truly exceptional performers from merely talented ones. He points to Tom Brady as an example—still angry about the Super Bowls he didn't win—and sees this same competitive drive translate to business success.
Rubin describes Fanatics' evolution from a $7 billion fan gear commerce business (starting 2011) to a diversified platform with three primary businesses: Fanatics Commerce (fan gear), betting and gaming (fastest growing sportsbook in the country), and collectibles (grown from $500 million first year to $5.5 billion in five years). He emphasizes that his best customers engage across multiple business lines rather than in isolation.
In collectibles, Rubin saw an opportunity in a massive but stagnant market dominated by companies like Panini and Topps that were perpetually for sale or focused on extraction rather than innovation. When COVID temporarily boosted the market, Rubin guaranteed sports properties (leagues and player unions) the "high watermark" of revenue while offering higher royalty rates, equity in a new secondary marketplace company (Fanatics Collect), and aggressive product innovation. Leagues went from making approximately $30 million to $150 million annually.
Rubin introduced product innovations including debut patches (singular cards created from patches worn during a player's first game), achievement-based cards, and collaborations with artists like George Kondo. These innovations transformed collectibles from a static category into an expanding market. He notes the secondary market (Fanatics Collect) now does $6-7 billion in GMV annually after just three years.
On deal-making and negotiation, Rubin has learned to prioritize long-term partnerships over winning individual transactions. He references Sam Zell's approach of paying slightly higher interest rates to build decades-long relationships with bankers. Similarly, when Fanatics' acquisition of Mitchell Ness went poorly, Rubin gave investors their money back rather than force them to absorb losses, prioritizing reputation and relationship longevity.
Rubin's investor relations have been consistently positive, crediting his self-deprecating nature, listening skills, and willingness to accept input from advisors like Greg Lemkow at Silver Lake, who recently intervened to prevent Rubin from making a major strategic mistake. He emphasizes that listening, not just talking, is crucial to long-term success.
About this episode
Michael Rubin is the founder and CEO of Fanatics. He grew up outside Philadelphia, started tuning skis at 12, opened a ski shop in his parents' basement at 13, and had a storefront in a shopping center by 14. At 16, after a winter without snow, he was facing $200,000 in bills and thought he was going bankrupt, until he learned minors can't legally take on debt. He settled for $35,000, then bought a bankrupt store's $200,000 of inventory for $13,000. That deal got him into the closeout business, and by 21 he was doing $150 million a year. Michael tells the story of nearly being margined out of GSI Commerce during the 2009 financial crisis, with hours to spare, two years before eBay bought it for $2.4 billion. He explains how Fanatics grew from a fan gear business into a $14 billion digital sports platform with 140 million customers, why he guaranteed the leagues the high watermark of a cyclical trading card market, and how debut patches and George Condo–painted cards turned collectibles into "art for sports fans." He also shares the advice Robert Kraft gave him when a partner broke a deal, why he gave investors their money back on NFTs and Mitchell & Ness, why there's a "0.0 chance" he'd put his own money into prediction markets at today's valuations, and the call from Silver Lake's Greg Mondre that saved him from a multibillion-dollar mistake. Show notes: https://www.davidsenra.com/episode/michael-rubin Made possible by Ramp: https://router.com AppLovin: https://applovin.com/senra Deel: https://deel.com/senra Chapters (00:00:00) Why so many billionaires are boring (00:03:47) Robert Kraft told him to sleep on it (00:08:25) How he almost went bankrupt at 16 (00:11:44) Hours from being margined out in 2009 (00:15:20) What a real entrepreneur is (00:17:21) "I'll stop playing when my heart stops beating" (00:21:03) The litigation, and why he loves the fight (00:25:12) "It's a currency of sports" (00:29:37) Selling more products to the fans they already have (00:32:42) "Number 3 is irrelevant, number 2 sucks, number 1 is everything" (00:33:48) "0.0 chance" he'd invest in prediction markets (00:35:49) $5.5 billion in collectibles (00:39:57) The debut patch: a $50 million card (00:45:14) "There was never an easier conversation" (00:50:00) "This is stupid": raising over $100 million and giving it back (00:53:26) "It's art for sports fans" (00:59:37) Winning the partnership, not the deal (01:06:19) "You saved me from something really dumb" Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Key Insights
- Rubin argues that billionaires are often boring because they accumulate wealth without engaging in interesting, authentic storytelling—what people actually want to hear are entrepreneurial stories that include failures and self-deprecation.
- Rubin claims he nearly went bankrupt at age 16 by overextending himself in the ski business when it didn't snow, settling $200,000 in debt for $35,000, then leveraging that crisis to build a $150 million business by age 21.
- Rubin states that during the 2008 financial crisis, when his $250 million stock portfolio dropped 90%, he was hours away from losing his entire company until a hedge fund manager finally agreed to return $5 million after receiving approximately 100 phone calls.
- Rubin defines a 'real' entrepreneur as someone born with entrepreneurial drive who loves the work and can't stop—distinguishing them from wealthy people who sell companies and become passive investors who no longer have passion in their blood.
- Rubin argues that relationships are most critical during crises, not during success—when things go wrong, relationships get tested, and having strong partnerships is what enables navigation through tough situations.
- Rubin claims that Fanatics' major competitive advantage in sports betting wasn't superior product design but rather having 70-80 million (later 140 million) existing customers already trusting the brand, allowing organic growth while competitors spent billions on advertising.
- Rubin states that he entered the collectibles market by guaranteeing sports leagues and unions the 'high watermark' revenue while offering higher royalties, equity participation, and product innovation—transforming their annual revenue from ~$30 million to ~$150 million.
- Rubin argues that the collectibles industry was stagnant because companies like Panini and Topps focused on extraction rather than innovation, always being for sale rather than investing in product development and marketing.
- Rubin claims he innovated the collectibles category by introducing debut patches (singular one-of-one cards from players' first games) and achievement-based cards, which became the most desired products and drove category growth beyond previous expectations.
- Rubin states his philosophy on deal-making shifted from trying to 'win' negotiations to building long-term partnerships, sometimes even paying higher costs or accepting less favorable terms to demonstrate commitment and build decades-long relationships.
- Rubin argues that his self-deprecating personality, willingness to listen to advisors, and openness to being told he's wrong (as Greg Lemkow recently did about a major strategic initiative) has been crucial to his success and longevity.
- Rubin claims that studying elite athletes reveals that killer instinct—the competitive drive to always win and improve—is the distinguishing factor between merely talented people and truly exceptional performers, a trait he's learned to apply to business.
Topics
Transcript
Tell me why you find so many billionaires boring. I think when you look at all the people that lead so many different businesses, you can accumulate huge wealth, but that doesn't mean you're interesting. If you go out and talk to a general person, you're like, hey, here's some rich guy who made all this money on Wall Street. That's not interesting to most people. What people like to hear is entrepreneurial stories. They want to hear, by the way, not about just all the good shit, but about the shit that went wrong. So I think someone who's self-deprecating, I'm one of the most self-deprecating people in the world. People like to hear their stories, like to hear…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from David Senra
How Mark Zuckerberg, Palmer Luckey, Josh Kushner & Scott Wu Think | Jeremy Stern
Jeremy Stern discusses his long-form profile writing process, covering his pieces on Mark Zuckerberg, Palmer Luckey, Scott Wu, and Josh Kushner. He explains how he approaches profiling major tech figures by starting with a question or theme rather than the person, conducting extensive interviews, and using literary techniques to reveal deeper truths about their psychology and motivations.
Bringing AI to the Real Economy | Alexander Taubman
Alexander Taubman of Long Lake discusses the company's $6.3 billion acquisition of American Express Global Business Travel and explains Long Lake's thesis of deploying frontier AI into established businesses across multiple industries. The conversation covers Long Lake's operating model, Nexus platform, rapid scaling to 30,000+ employees across 5 verticals, and the long-term vision to build a trillion-dollar company while maintaining profitability and employee growth.
Building the Streetwear Empire Kith | Ronnie Fieg
Ronnie Fieg, founder and CEO of Kith, discusses his journey from a working-class kid in Queens obsessed with sneakers to building a global streetwear and lifestyle empire. He emphasizes the importance of passion-driven entrepreneurship, meticulous product curation, and maintaining creative control by refusing wholesale and licensing deals.
Doug Leone on Sequoia, Fear, Great Founders & Starting Over at 69
Doug Leone, Sequoia Capital partner, discusses how he has dominated his field for decades by constantly reinventing himself out of fear of becoming irrelevant, using fear as a motivator rather than a hindrance. He shares his philosophy on identifying exceptional founders, building trust-based business relationships, and constructing effective boards, while reflecting on his return to active investing at age 69 after a four-year retirement.
Building Defense Technologies to Protect Democracies | Torsten Reil, Helsing
Torsten Reil, founder of Helsing, discusses how modern warfare is fundamentally shifting from traditional vehicles and manned aircraft to autonomous drone swarms and AI-controlled systems, driven by rapid technological advancement and the lessons from Ukraine. He argues that European defense capabilities require aggressive founders with high talent density, mass manufacturing of simple hardware paired with sophisticated software, and an unwavering commitment to building companies that matter rather than selling out.