OpinionDiscussion

Stocks Rally While Crude Oil Collapses! What It Means

Crowded Market Report

The speaker reflects on a day of significant market misjudgments following the November 4th, 2026 election results showing a Democrat sweep. Despite most positions making theoretical sense, actual market movements contradicted his bearish NASDAQ stance, bullish crude oil position, and skepticism about precious metals, prompting him to emphasize the importance of sticking to systematic trading processes over directional predictions.

Summary

On November 4th, 2026, the day after a significant Democratic election sweep, the speaker openly acknowledges having been wrong on multiple major market calls throughout the trading day. He begins by noting he was short the NASDAQ, which declined only 300 points—significantly underperforming the Dow's gains of approximately 1,700 points. He theorizes this made some fundamental sense given Democratic policies could be seen as negative for AI businesses and tech more broadly.

Regarding bonds, the speaker had been bearish throughout, but bonds rallied again and hit new highs. He rationalizes this could make sense if Democrats pursue inflation reduction or tax increases, which would theoretically slow economic growth and lower bond yields. The dollar declined alongside bonds in a pattern consistent with slower growth expectations.

However, crude oil proved to be his most significant miss. Previously bullish on crude with expectations for continued higher prices, crude collapsed nearly 8% on the day. The speaker speculates this could reflect slower economic growth expectations and reduced geopolitical tensions in the Middle East without Trump's policies, both bearish for oil demand and risk premium.

Precious metals were another major disappointment to his thesis. He had specifically stated in a previous video that he didn't believe in a large move up in gold and silver, expecting further downside. Instead, gold surged $135 (a significant move) and silver rose 5.5%, with the speaker attributing this to broad unwind and reversal trading.

Bitcoin followed the stock market's gains, though the speaker notes the NASDAQ didn't make new highs and "doesn't really trade that great." Interestingly, the German DAX became the first major market to achieve new all-time highs. The speaker questions whether this is a Trump 2016-like scenario, but notes that positioning and psychology were very different then, and the election results constituted a surprise given a 65% probability had been priced in for the sweep.

The core lesson the speaker extracts from the day is a reinforcement of his trading philosophy: don't abandon process and systematic trading for confidence in directional calls, no matter how accurate recent predictions have been. He emphasizes that his process focuses on risk-reward positioning, sentiment, and market action—not prediction. He acknowledges losing money on his short NASDAQ position but notes it remains profitable overall and that stops will protect against major losses. Finally, he previews the employment report coming Friday as a potential source of volatility.

Key Insights

  • The speaker was short NASDAQ but it only declined 300 points versus the Dow's 1,700-point gain, despite theoretical fundamental reasoning suggesting tech should underperform under Democratic governance
  • Bonds rallied to new highs despite the speaker's bearish stance, which he rationalizes could make sense if Democrats pursue policies that slow economic growth and lower yields
  • Crude oil crashed nearly 8% despite the speaker's bullish outlook, likely reflecting expectations of slower economic growth and reduced Middle East geopolitical tensions without Trump administration policies
  • Gold surged $135 and silver rose 5.5%, contradicting the speaker's prior assertion that he didn't believe in a big move up in precious metals, which he attributes to broad market unwind and reversals
  • The speaker emphasizes that trading success comes from high risk-reward positioning, sentiment, and market action analysis rather than from calling market direction correctly, regardless of recent prediction accuracy

Topics

Election aftermath and market reactionsNASDAQ underperformance versus DowBonds rally despite bearish expectationsCrude oil collapse and geopolitical factorsPrecious metals surge (gold and silver)Trading process versus directional predictionRisk management and stop lossesMarket positioning and sentiment

Transcript

[0:00] I can't think of a day where I have had more things wrong to the extent that I am wrong than today. This video is brought to you by Kelshi, CMR's first official sponsor. Learn more about their perpetual futures contracts like the S&P 500, gold, and Bitcoin by clicking the link in the video description, which helps support CMR and allows us to continue to publish free premium content. Thank you. Okay, everybody. How we doing? It's Wednesday, November 4th, 2026. The day after the big election day and [0:31] the Democrat big sweep. Where do we start? I guess I'll start with this. I can't think of a day where I have had more things wrong to…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Crowded Market Report

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.