NewsInvestigative Research

What Kalshi And Polymarket Mean For Election Integrity: Gamble On Democracy

CNBC

A CNBC investigation reveals that prediction market platforms Kalshi and Polymarket experienced suspicious price spikes and anomalies during the 2026 LA mayoral race, raising concerns about market manipulation and potential threats to election integrity as these platforms increasingly influence voter behavior.

Summary

The transcript examines prediction markets—specifically Kalshi and Polymarket—which allow users to trade contracts on election outcomes and other events. These platforms have grown substantially, with over $47 million in bets placed on the 2026 Los Angeles mayoral race alone, and viewership outnumbering traders by a 5-to-1 ratio for midterm elections. The Anti-Corruption Data Collective (ACDC) conducted an exclusive analysis for CNBC revealing concerning anomalies in the LA race, where prediction market odds giving Spencer Pratt a 78% chance of advancing proved wildly inaccurate when he finished third.

ACDC identified several red flags: repeated price recoveries following negative news about Pratt that weren't seen for other candidates, and a single $56,000 purchase that temporarily spiked Pratt's odds to 99 cents while losing the buyer approximately $8,000 in potential profit—suggesting a motivation beyond profit-seeking. The analysis also found that across 167 congressional markets worth over $100,000, approximately 23% experienced significant price spikes of 30 cents or more. In the Illinois Democratic Senate race, a $5,000 purchase moved Stratton's odds from 47 to 79 cents, which normalized within seconds but then spiked to 99 cents after additional $3,000 in purchases—a pattern suggesting possible coordination.

Kalshi and Polymarket defend their platforms as self-correcting markets with built-in incentives against manipulation. Kalshi claims its markets have accurately predicted outcomes nine times out of ten since 2024, and both platforms emphasize that rational traders have financial incentives to correct mispriced markets. However, ACDC's analysis of Kalshi's own case study on the Pratt race revealed limitations: while Kalshi highlighted a price correction within seconds, the three-hour window showed continued buying that elevated prices by 3%, which could influence voter perceptions.

Regulatory approaches differ between platforms. Kalshi is CFTC-regulated and requires Know Your Customer (KYC) information, with publicly visible trading prices and activity. Polymarket U.S. is similarly regulated, but Polymarket International—the larger platform—does not require KYC information, instead relying on blockchain transparency. Polymarket International partnered with blockchain analytics firm Chainalysis to detect suspicious activity, and the collaboration identified a U.S. soldier using classified information to bet on Venezuelan political outcomes. However, this case was initially flagged by journalists and social media rather than the platform itself.

Election officials express deep concern about the impact on election integrity. Maryland State Board of Elections administrator Jared Demarinis warned that prediction markets amplify scrutiny and apprehension about election validity, and he has requested investigation into whether prediction markets violate state gambling laws. The LA County Clerk's office noted that prediction market projections can add confusion when treated as more authoritative than actual vote counts. More than half of U.S. states have laws prohibiting election betting, though questions remain about whether these apply to federally-regulated prediction markets. A key vulnerability remains: 88% of nearly 18,000 congressional markets could have their prices moved by 10 cents with a single bet under $1,000, especially when liquidity is thin.

Key Insights

  • ACDC found that 23% of 167 congressional markets worth over $100,000 experienced price spikes moving contract prices 30 cents or more, and 88% of nearly 18,000 active congressional markets could have their prices moved by 10 cents with a single bet under $1,000
  • In the LA mayoral race, a trader spent $56,000 on Spencer Pratt contracts, lost $8,000 in potential profit, and the price continued to rise over a three-hour window by 3% even though Kalshi's case study only showed a nine-second correction
  • Kalshi claims that across U.S. elections since 2024, when its markets favored a candidate, that candidate won roughly nine times out of ten, demonstrating market accuracy despite identified price spikes
  • Polymarket International does not require Know Your Customer information but claims that about 95% of volume originates from known KYC sources through blockchain exchanges, allowing identification of suspicious wallets
  • Maryland election official Jared Demarinis expressed concern that prediction markets will amplify heightened scrutiny and apprehension about election validity, and requested investigation into whether they violate state gambling laws

Topics

Prediction markets (Kalshi and Polymarket)Election integrity and voter manipulationMarket anomalies and price spikesPlatform regulation and oversightInsider trading detectionElection betting legality

Transcript

[0:04] This is a machine. If we want to burn this town to the ground- The race for mayor of Los Angeles was unconventional in every way. You can do it, Spencer. Let him in. Former TV reality show star Spencer Pratt versus a city council member and the incumbent mayor in the June primary. I know what the consequences of failed leadership are. That's why I'm running for mayor. AI-generated campaign ads and prediction markets [0:34] buzzing with activity. In fact, it is the highest-traded mayoral race in 2026, surpassing $47 million in bets, a highly liquid market that theoretically should reflect the will of the people. Raman overtook reality star turned wannabe politician Spencer Pratt. Except it didn't.…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from CNBC

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.