How AI is 'snipping the career ladder off at the bottom'
AI is reducing entry-level job opportunities for young workers, particularly in highly AI-exposed fields. Research suggests ChatGPT's release correlates with a 9% drop in early-career hires, equivalent to roughly 150,000 lost jobs. Experts warn this trend risks dismantling the foundational step of career development.
Summary
The transcript explores how AI is disrupting the traditional career entry pathway for young workers, particularly those who followed the conventional college-to-office route. Labor market researchers note that younger workers in AI-exposed jobs are experiencing the greatest disruption, even though this hasn't yet manifested as broad layoffs in headline employment figures.
One researcher found a direct correlation between the release of ChatGPT and a 9% immediate drop in hiring, translating to approximately 150,000 lost early-career jobs in the observable period following the release. While the researcher acknowledges difficulty in attributing the entire decline solely to AI, the data suggests AI is a meaningful contributing factor.
A critical distinction is drawn between layoffs and hiring slowdowns. Companies are still filling roles that require several years of experience, but entry-level positions are disappearing. This creates a paradox: the pipeline that produces experienced workers is being cut off at its source.
Experts emphasize that senior-level skill is not built in classrooms but through on-the-job learning alongside more experienced colleagues. By eliminating junior roles, companies are effectively removing the bottom rung of the career ladder, which threatens the long-term development of skilled workers across AI-exposed industries.
Key Insights
- A researcher found an immediate 9% drop in hires following ChatGPT's release, which accounts for approximately 150,000 lost early-career jobs in the observed period.
- AI's labor market impact has not appeared as broad layoffs in headline jobs numbers, but is instead showing up as a reduction in new hiring — a more subtle but significant disruption.
- Researchers observe that jobs requiring several years of experience are still plentiful, but entry-level positions specifically are the ones disappearing from the market.
- One expert argues that the bulk of professional skill development comes from doing the job alongside more experienced workers — not from formal education — meaning reduced junior hiring undermines future talent pipelines.
- The strongest labor market evidence so far indicates that younger workers in the most AI-exposed jobs are likely experiencing the greatest degree of disruption from AI adoption.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] For many young people who followed the traditional college to office path, that first rung of the career ladder is getting harder to reach. >> The strongest evidence we have so far in the labor market data is that it's younger workers in the more exposed jobs that are likely experiencing the greatest disruption. >> What I find is an immediate 9% drop in hires after Chat GPT was released. This is the cause of an explanation for a loss of about 150,000 early career jobs [0:34] over the period that I'm able to observe after CHP was released. It's really hard for us to say that every piece of this decline is specifically because of AI, but it…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from CNBC
How AI Super PACs Are Shaping The Midterms
AI-backed super PACs spent tens of millions during the midterms, with rival groups backed by OpenAI and Anthropic clashing over AI regulation policy. The competing PACs influenced congressional races, particularly one in New York where they opposed and supported different candidates based on their stance on AI regulation.
How Warsh's Task Forces Will Reshape The Federal Reserve
Fed Chair Kevin Warsh is establishing five task forces to reshape the Federal Reserve's approach to monetary policy, focusing on artificial intelligence's deflationary potential, modernizing inflation measurement beyond PCE, improving economic data collection, restructuring Fed communications, and reducing the central bank's balance sheet.
How Trump's $1.8B 'lawfare' fund works
The Justice Department created a $1.776 billion anti-weaponization fund to compensate people allegedly harmed by lawfare, established as part of a settlement where Trump and his family dropped a $10 billion lawsuit against the IRS over tax return leaks. The fund and an accompanying tax provision shielding Trump from IRS enforcement have generated bipartisan criticism and legal challenges, with Democrats concerned it could become a slush fund for Trump's political allies.
How Asian food is reshaping mainstream grocery stores
Asian groceries have become a major market force worth $37 billion, with specialized retailers like H Mart, 99 Ranch, and Patel Brothers leading the category. As demand for Asian flavors grows, mainstream grocery chains like Whole Foods are now competing directly with traditional Asian grocery stores for consumer interest.
Who Is Funding Pres. Trump’s Freedom 250 Celebrations?
A CNBC investigation examines how the Trump administration's Freedom 250 entity has allegedly diverted approximately $100 million in taxpayer funds intended for the bipartisan America 250 commission, raising ethics concerns about corporate sponsorships and potential conflicts of interest involving major federal contractors.