We bought a 140-year-old house in New Jersey for $550,000
Amanda and Vinny Drees purchased a 140-year-old Victorian home in Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey for $550,000. The couple has been renovating the money pit ever since, discovering fascinating historical artifacts inside the walls. Amanda grew up dreaming of owning a Victorian home, while Vinny was less prepared for the extensive renovation work involved.
Summary
Amanda (32) and Vinny (34) Drees share their experience of purchasing a 140-year-old Victorian home in Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey for $550,000. Despite their realtor labeling it a 'money pit,' Amanda saw the potential in the home and was drawn to its vision from the start.
The home is a five-bedroom, two-bathroom Victorian property located two blocks from the water. Vinny walks to a nearby ferry each morning for his commute to work, making the location a key factor in their decision to purchase. The couple converted the originally six-bedroom layout by removing one wall to create a more open space.
One of the most exciting aspects of the renovation has been uncovering historical artifacts hidden within the walls. Among the discoveries were a vintage breast pump, a Stan Musial 1948 rookie baseball card, and handwritten letters dating back to the 1930s. These finds have deepened the couple's appreciation for the history embedded in the home.
Amanda shares that she has always been fascinated by old Victorian homes, inspired in part by playing with dollhouses growing up. She once considered such homes out of financial reach, making their purchase feel like a dream realized. Vinny, by contrast, was less prepared for the scale of renovation work the house would require, something Amanda acknowledges with humor.
Key Insights
- Their realtor described the house as a 'money pit,' but Amanda disagreed and saw significant potential in the property from the beginning.
- The couple discovered remarkable historical artifacts inside the walls during renovation, including a vintage breast pump, a Stan Musial 1948 rookie baseball card, and handwritten letters from the 1930s.
- Vinny walks to a ferry each morning for his work commute, making proximity to the water a major factor in choosing the Atlantic Highlands location.
- Amanda says she was always drawn to Victorian homes growing up but assumed they were financially out of reach, making this purchase feel like an unlikely dream fulfilled.
- Amanda acknowledges that Vinny did not fully anticipate the extent of renovation work the 140-year-old home would require when they decided to buy it.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access