I Used An AI Tool To Do My Taxes – Here's Where Experts Say I Went Wrong
A journalist tested using ChatGPT to help with taxes involving capital gains from stock sales, but discovered significant errors when consulting a CPA. The experiment highlights risks of AI tax advice, including outdated training data, overly confident responses, and the potential for users to accept answers without proper verification.
Summary
The author typically has straightforward taxes but faced complexity after selling employee stock purchase plan shares for wedding funds, potentially triggering capital gains tax. Instead of consulting a tax professional, they decided to test AI assistance, joining the more than 20% of taxpayers planning to use AI for 2025 taxes. Using a paid corporate version of ChatGPT that wouldn't use their data for training, they uploaded their consolidated 1099 and received what seemed like helpful, easy-to-follow advice broken into bullet points. However, when double-checking with a CPA, they discovered the AI's guidance was flawed. The tax professional explained that AI models tend to give definitive answers when the reality is 'it depends,' and people often stop reading after getting the answer they want to hear. The number ChatGPT presented as 'almost certainly right' actually needed manual calculation and verification, and the AI missed problematic data in the 1099 because the user didn't know to ask about it. Tax professionals noted that large language models may be trained on outdated information that could be 9-18 months old or older, which is problematic given frequent tax law changes. For those using AI for taxes, experts recommend using thinking models rather than instant chatbots, being aware of data privacy policies, and always double-checking with tax experts, as the IRS won't accept 'the AI made me do it' as a valid excuse for mistakes.
Key Insights
- More than one in five taxpayers say they're planning on using AI to help file their 2025 taxes
- AI models give definitive answers to tax questions when professionals would say 'it depends,' and many people stop reading after getting the answer they want to hear
- ChatGPT missed problematic data in the 1099 form because the user didn't think to ask about it specifically
- Large language models may be trained on data that is 9 or 18 months old or much older, which is problematic since tax laws change frequently
- If you make a mistake while using AI to do your taxes, the IRS won't accept 'Well, the AI made me do it' as a valid excuse
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Tax time for me is usually pretty straightforward. I get my W2, enter the information into my tax software, E file, and I'm done. But last year was a little different. To raise funds for my upcoming wedding, I sold most of the shares I had bought over the years [music] through my company's employee stock purchase plan. And that meant I might owe capital gains tax. But instead of asking a tax pro for advice, I tested out an increasingly popular route. [music] More than one in five taxpayers say they're planning on using AI to help file their 2025 taxes. [music] I was a little skeptical about trusting [0:31] an AI chatbot with my taxes, but any…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from CNBC Make It
I scaled back my six-figure career to run a local bookstore with my husband — here's why
A couple shares their experience transitioning from a six-figure career to running a local bookstore together, emphasizing that their reduced income and lifestyle change has brought greater happiness and fulfillment despite financial uncertainty. They reflect on how overcoming initial fear about the transition has made the experience exciting rather than scary.
'Hard work will speak for itself' is a lie, says Stanford career expert
Stanford career expert Jeffrey Pfeffer argues that the belief that hard work alone leads to success is false. Instead, how you present yourself and your visibility to leadership matters as much as or more than the actual work you do, making relationship-building with your boss essential for career advancement.
Here's why Jim Cramer named his dog 'Nvidia'
Jim Cramer explains how he renamed his dog Nvidia in 2017 to promote the stock, which he calls empirically the greatest stock of all time. He claims this marketing stunt helped create numerous millionaires, with a $10,000 investment turning into $454,000.
Are We 'Maxxing' Too Much?
The transcript explores the 'maxing' trend—optimizing every aspect of life from sleep to fiber intake—examining why it has become popular amid global uncertainty and how brands capitalize on this behavior. Experts warn that while self-improvement is valuable, approaching maxing with obsessive rigidity can be counterproductive, and individuals should prioritize sustainability and psychological flexibility.
Are you making this mistake on dating apps?
A psychologist identifies the primary mistake people make on dating apps: entering without clarity on what they actually want. Without internal criteria, users react superficially to appearance and pursue matches based on who shows interest, rather than making deliberate choices aligned with their actual goals.