Working-class kids 'left behind' in Grimsby
John Ellis, who has run the Shalom Youth Center in East Marsh for 54 years, warns that the education system is failing working-class young people in Grimsby. Several youth at the center openly admit to avoiding school for months, finding it boring and disengaging. Ellis argues that academy-style education has improved outcomes for high-achieving students but has moved further from the culture of disadvantaged young people.
Summary
The transcript opens with a young person expressing a lack of self-belief, stating they expect to do badly in school and feel incapable. This sets the tone for a broader discussion about educational disengagement among working-class youth in Grimsby's East Marsh area.
John Ellis, who has run the Shalom Youth Center for 54 years, expresses deep concern about what he describes as a growing and unprecedented problem. He notes that over the past 12 months, for the first time in his experience, young people are telling him they simply do not go anywhere or engage with any form of education.
Several young people at the center are interviewed directly, with one admitting to not attending school for around three months, another saying they were kicked out, and others describing school as boring and chaotic — claiming that no real learning took place because everyone was misbehaving.
Ellis estimates that around 15 to 20 young people who frequent the center are all in a similar situation, receiving only a couple of hours of schooling per day. He offers a critical perspective on the academy school system, suggesting that while it may have raised standards for higher-achieving students, it has been a disaster for the young people he works with, as it has drifted further from their lived cultural experience.
The transcript ends on a note of aspiration but uncertainty, with one young person expressing a desire for a good job and acknowledging that school is likely necessary to achieve it — highlighting the tension between their goals and their disengagement from the system meant to help them reach those goals.
Key Insights
- A young person at the center expresses no self-belief in their academic ability, stating outright that they expect to do badly in school and feel they simply cannot do it.
- John Ellis states that over the past 12 months, for the first time in his 54 years running the center, young people are telling him they do not go anywhere and are entirely disengaged from any form of education.
- Young people interviewed at the center openly admit to avoiding school for months, citing boredom, exclusion, and a chaotic classroom environment where no learning occurred.
- John Ellis estimates that approximately 15 to 20 young people regularly at the center are all in the same situation, receiving only a couple of hours of schooling per day.
- Ellis argues that the academy school system has improved education for high-achieving students but has been a disaster for the working-class young people he supports, because it has moved further away from the culture they live in.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access