DiscussionInsightful

1229: Finding the True Cost of Connectivity | Sarah Taylor, CFO, MCNC

CFO THOUGHT LEADER28m 17s

Sarah Taylor, CFO of MCNC (a nonprofit telecommunications provider in North Carolina), discusses her career path from retail to finance leadership and shares how she's introduced greater financial discipline through project ROI analysis, stronger cost visibility, and five-year forecasting without compromising the organization's mission to serve underserved communities.

Summary

Sarah Taylor began her career in retail management before pivoting to accounting during college. She worked at a small public accounting firm where she gained broad exposure across industries and audit work, then spent over a decade at Memorial Care where her responsibilities expanded into business intelligence and clinical operations. This business intelligence experience proved transformative, helping her understand data governance and quality—skills she now applies to financial planning and modeling at MCNC.

MCNC is a nonprofit telecommunications provider in North Carolina that owns and operates 5,000 miles of fiber optic network, serving K-12 schools, higher education, healthcare, and government agencies. The organization generates all revenue from connectivity and technology services rather than donor solicitation, though it applies for relevant grants.

Upon becoming CFO, Taylor introduced significant changes to how MCNC evaluates investments. Previously, the organization would proceed with projects if external funding was available, even if MCNC's own investment wouldn't be recouped. Taylor shifted this approach by requiring rigorous ROI analysis and cost visibility. She illustrated this with a fiber expansion project that looked promising due to state appropriations but didn't pencil out when MCNC's substantial capital contribution was factored in. The leadership team ultimately rejected the project—a departure from past practice.

Taylor implemented new financial reporting focused on operating margin and days cash on hand as key performance metrics, replacing detailed full financial statements to the board with targeted metric discussions. She's also introduced five-year forecasting while managing colleague expectations that these projections represent directional guidance rather than fixed targets. The core theme she communicates is year-over-year margin improvement, which signals better operational efficiency and optimization.

A major undertaking involves re-implementing NetSuite and overhauling the chart of accounts to provide better visibility into true business costs—a critical challenge given the complexity of allocating costs across a large fiber infrastructure. Taylor emphasizes the importance of curiosity in building rapport across the organization, leveraging relationships to deliver difficult financial messages more effectively. She sees AI opportunities primarily in automating routine employee tasks during departures to avoid burnout and in improving forecasting through shared modeling across the organization.

About this episode

<p>The opportunity looked promising. MCNC could extend its fiber-optic network into another part of North Carolina, potentially with some financial support from the state. But when CFO Sarah Taylor examined the proposed investment, the numbers told a different story.</p><p>“It just didn’t pencil,” Taylor recalls.</p><p>For MCNC, a nonprofit that operates a 5,000-mile fiber network serving schools, healthcare organizations, universities, and government agencies, such decisions carry particular weight. Expanding connectivity into underserved communities remains central to its mission. Yet Taylor believes that mission must coexist with a clearer understanding of investment returns and operating costs.</p><p>Her approach is helping change how MCNC evaluates opportunities. Rather than viewing outside funding as sufficient justification for a project, Taylor asks what the organization itself must contribute, which customers it expects to serve, and whether the investment makes financial sense.</p><p>That discipline extends to financial reporting. Taylor has shifted board presentations away from full financial statements toward deeper discussions of operating margin and days cash on hand. She’s also introduced five-year forecasting, emphasizing continuous margin improvement rather than rigid adherence to distant targets.</p><p>Her earlier experience bridging finance and business intelligence at MemorialCare helped shape this approach. There, she learned how data quality and cross-functional understanding could transform financial planning.</p><p>Now Taylor is preparing another substantial change: reimplementing NetSuite and overhauling MCNC’s chart of accounts to expose the true costs of running the network.</p><p>For Taylor, better financial visibility isn’t simply about producing better reports. It’s about making better decisions with the dollars MCNC has available.</p>

Key Insights

  • Taylor's experience in business intelligence and working with IT teams fundamentally changed how she approaches financial planning by teaching her the importance of data quality, governance, and the disconnect between what business units request and what technology teams can deliver.
  • At MCNC, the presence of external funding (state appropriations) previously created a bias toward project approval regardless of the organization's own return on investment; Taylor shifted this by requiring rigorous analysis of MCNC's capital contribution and expected payback period.
  • Taylor views five-year forecasts as 'living, breathing documents' and communicates that organizational success is measured by year-over-year margin improvement rather than hitting specific percentage targets, helping colleagues understand the purpose of the planning exercise.
  • Taylor identifies curiosity—consistently asking peers, vendors, and colleagues about their goals and the reasoning behind processes—as the core behavior that shaped her career and enabled her to build strong working relationships that facilitate difficult financial conversations.
  • Taylor prioritizes using AI to eliminate or minimize tasks performed by departing employees rather than hiring replacements, viewing this as a way to reduce burnout while generating compounded year-over-year savings.

Topics

Career progression from retail to CFOFinancial discipline and ROI analysis in nonprofit contextCost visibility and infrastructure investment decisionsFive-year forecasting and margin-focused planningBuilding organizational relationships and change managementAI applications in finance and operations

Transcript

Support for CFO Thought Leader comes from OneStream, Trusted Data, Faster Decisions, and Salesforce. Explore new research on the future of finance and AI at salesforce.com slash CFO report. Hello, this is Tom Steer, CFO of Sokin, and you are listening to the CFO Thought Leader podcast. This is episode 1229. The hard thing with five-year forecasts is they're really only accurate as of a point in time. And I know this, but it gets a little challenging for my colleagues when they're looking at some of those out years and they think that, oh, we must absolutely stick to that. And there's a bit of an education that, hey, this is kind of a living, breathing document that we…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from CFO THOUGHT LEADER

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.