Tana Mongeau: Internet Lore, Sobriety & Finding Love
Alex Cooper interviews Tana Mongeau on Call Her Daddy, where they discuss their complex history, Tana's evolution from a chaotic YouTube personality to a sober, intentional content creator, and her new podcast 'Brand Safe.' The conversation covers Tana's troubled upbringing, substance abuse, toxic relationships, and her current life with boyfriend Makoa in Hawaii.
Summary
The episode opens with Alex Cooper and Tana Mongeau reflecting on their complicated history, which began when Tana was supposed to be the first-ever Call Her Daddy guest but slept through the interview. They then had a dinner at Catch the night before Tana appeared on the show while living in the 'clout house,' an experience Tana largely cannot remember due to substance abuse. Their public interactions were often misread by fans as hostile, though both maintained a mutual respect and curiosity about each other that was never properly explored until a recent private lunch.
The conversation delves deeply into Tana's early YouTube career, where she deliberately did outrageous things for views and engagement, driven primarily by fear — fear of returning home to her abusive parents and fear of obscurity. She describes how the line between her real life and content became completely blurred, culminating in stunts like a fake wedding and living in the clout house surrounded by other influencers like the Paul brothers and Faze Banks. She acknowledges that unlike many peers, she lacked discretion entirely, sharing everything from drug use to personal trauma without filter.
Tana discusses her podcast 'Canceled,' co-hosted with Brooke, which she credits with saving her career. The show built a massive community of women who felt seen by the duo's unfiltered conversations, but toward the end, Tana began to feel the mental health toll of oversharing and living so publicly. She and Brooke have since parted ways professionally but remain close friends, and Tana expresses deep pride in both of their evolutions — symbolized by Brooke now peacefully watching bunnies in her backyard.
A significant portion of the episode covers Tana's sobriety, now over a year and a half old. She describes how her entire identity was wrapped up in being the party girl, and she genuinely feared becoming boring, unfunny, or irrelevant without alcohol. A turning point came when a fan at a meet-and-greet in Amsterdam told her that Tana had helped her get sober and that her parents 'wouldn't have a daughter' without Tana's influence. She now considers her sobriety her greatest achievement and is committed to showing her generation that sober can still be dynamic and fun.
The episode also covers Tana's painful family history. Her parents sued her for slander over her MTV show, despite the show depicting only a fraction of her actual childhood trauma. She ultimately settled the case — paying a large sum — because she was not mentally strong enough to continue fighting and feared she would not survive the prolonged legal battle. She has been no-contact with both parents since, though she recently had a final conversation with her birth mother, who is terminally ill. She grieves the relationship they never had and never will have.
Tana speaks warmly about her boyfriend Makoa, crediting him with helping her understand what healthy love looks like. She describes her previous relationships as defined by the belief that love must be earned and that highs only come after painful lows — a dynamic she compares to addiction. Makoa's patience and his family's unconditional acceptance have been transformative for her. She also speaks about her chosen family through her friend Amari and his family, who showed her what stable, loving family dynamics look like.
Finally, Tana introduces her new podcast 'Brand Safe,' which she describes as the most intentional creative project of her life, built around the phrase 'intention versus attention.' She emphasizes that she is no longer creating content to garner attention at any cost, but to be genuinely meaningful. She discusses broader themes of women being pressured to stay in one identity bucket, the double standard women face in the industry, and the importance of evolution and grace — especially for young women in their early twenties who are still figuring themselves out.
Key Insights
- Tana argues that fear — specifically of returning to her abusive parents and of irrelevance — was her single biggest career motivator for years, driving her to do increasingly outrageous things for attention.
- Tana claims she genuinely could not differentiate between her real life and her content persona, saying the party girl identity became so internalized that she lost herself entirely in it.
- Tana states that she believed sobriety would make her boring, unfunny, and cause her to lose her entire audience, a belief she now sees as completely false and rooted in fear.
- Tana argues that her parents sued her for slander over her MTV show despite the show depicting only a negligible fraction of how bad her actual childhood was, calling the lawsuit 'the most traumatizing period of her life.'
- Tana reveals she ultimately settled the lawsuit and paid her parents a large sum not because she believed she would lose, but because she felt she would not survive — either by suicide or overdose — if the case continued.
- Tana describes her previous approach to romantic relationships as believing love must be earned and that real love required highs and lows, which she directly compares to the cycle of drug addiction and chasing a high.
- Tana argues that the universe protected her from forming deep relationships until she was sober, suggesting many of her current meaningful connections — including with Alex Cooper — could only have happened at this point in her life.
- Tana claims that being publicly criticized, including Dave Portnoy calling her a 'bozo' and the fallout from TanaCon, did stick with her internally even during periods when she appeared indifferent, and that she was quietly trying to grow.
- Tana contends that society is deeply uncomfortable when a woman evolves, because it forces people to decide whether one version of her was fake — she argues both versions can be authentic at different life stages.
- Tana argues that the short-form content era has made the tendency to pit women against each other significantly worse, and that she now deliberately avoids scrolling TikTok because it consistently asks 'what new woman are we hating today.'
- Tana states that her new podcast 'Brand Safe' is built on the philosophy of 'intention versus attention,' marking the first time in her career she is creating content she finds morally meaningful rather than content designed to generate maximum views.
- Tana argues that content creators of her generation had no roadmap, no PR teams, and no examples to learn from, and were essentially figuring out influencer culture in real time — making mistakes that today's creators are shielded from by agencies and managers who have already seen those mistakes play out.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access