Emmy Rossum: Shameless, Motherhood & Knowing Your Worth
Emmy Rossum discusses her career trajectory from child opera singer to Shameless star, her fight for pay equity in Hollywood, her journey to motherhood through IVF, and her new production company's show 'Furious.' She shares personal stories about her single mother's influence, past relationships, and how she found stability with her current husband.
Summary
Emmy Rossum opens the interview sharing her deep passion for basketball and the New York Knicks, explaining that she watches sports for the emotional narrative and ability to see players' faces. She recounts laboring during a Knicks playoff game while pregnant with her daughter, eventually taking an Uber to the hospital where she was eight centimeters dilated.
Rossum reflects on her childhood with her single mother, Cheryl, a photographer and adventurous woman who worked for companies like Mobil Oil and was Steve Jobs' personal photographer. Her mother taught her survival through dramatic lessons, such as throwing her bedding out a fourth-floor window to illustrate what happens without income. Despite limited money, her mother prioritized Emmy's private school education and never made her feel financially insecure.
She traces her career from age seven singing at the Metropolitan Opera's Children's Chorus, to landing her first TV role at eleven, to starring in 'The Phantom of the Opera' at seventeen. Emmy was initially told by Shameless casting that she seemed "too princessy" based on her previous film roles, but she knew the character of Fiona Gallagher was hers. Playing Fiona for nearly a decade on a grueling set without sides (full scripts) or last looks created intense camaraderie with her castmates, particularly Jeremy Allen White.
A major focus of the interview is Emmy's fight for pay equity on Shameless. When contract renegotiations began in season three and later seasons, she and her team requested equal pay to male leads. After being denied, the negotiation leaked on Twitter, sparking public discussion that shifted the tide, and she secured equal pay within a day. Emmy reflects that this experience taught her the importance of taking up space and advocating for her worth, though she notes the double standard where men advocating for themselves are seen as strong while women are labeled difficult.
Regarding relationships, Emmy discusses a pattern of intensity in her early dating life. Her first serious relationship at eighteen involved a man who shut down the Palace of Versailles for a second date. After two consecutive painful breakups, she impulsively married Justin at twenty-one after knowing him only a couple months when he presented it as marry-or-break-up before she left for six months to film in Mexico. She realized the marriage was a mistake and eventually divorced.
She spent nearly a decade searching for the right partner before meeting her now-husband Sam Esmail on the set of a film he wrote and directed. His letter introducing the project impressed her with its honesty about his insecurities, therapy, and passion for filmmaking. They developed feelings over a year of collaboration, and after he confessed his love before filming began, they eventually kissed and have been together for fourteen years. Emmy notes that watching Sam be an exceptional father to their daughters has been deeply healing given her complicated relationship with her own father, whom she met only once as a child (the "we don't cut our spaghetti guy").
On motherhood, Emmy shares the "pancake problem"—a story where she broke her foot trying to shower, make pancakes, and get to a 16-hour shoot day to prove her love to her ten-month-old daughter. This experience taught her to do less in order to avoid total depletion, though she continues balancing ambitious work with parenting her three and five-year-old children.
Finally, Emmy discusses her new show 'Furious,' produced by her production company, which she both stars in and executive produces. The show follows Alice, a former NYPD detective turned FBI agent investigating a serial killer, exploring themes of female rage, moral gray areas, and the complications women in law enforcement face when reporting abuse from partners in the same system. Emmy explains she was drawn to exploring uncomfortable themes and characters that don't fit neatly into hero or villain categories.
About this episode
Join Alex in the studio for an interview with Emmy Rossum. Emmy reflects on being raised by a single mother, what drew her to the role of Fiona Gallagher, her favorite memories from filming Shameless, and her fight for pay equity on the series. She also opens up about the relationship lessons she's learned, motherhood, and the next chapter of her career. Enjoy!
Key Insights
- Emmy was initially rejected for Shameless because casting thought she was 'too princessy' based on her previous high-profile film roles, but she knew she was right for Fiona and trusted her own instincts as an actor.
- The Shameless set operated without sides (full scripts) or last looks, creating a grueling but highly disciplined environment where cast and crew had to arrive fully prepared, resulting in intense bonding over 10-16 hour days for nine years.
- Emmy's pay equity negotiation on Shameless remained private until it leaked on Twitter, which actually helped her case by sparking public outrage that shifted negotiations in her favor within a day.
- Emmy recognizes a double standard where men advocating for their worth in salary negotiations are perceived as strong and strategic, while women advocating for themselves risk being labeled difficult or ungrateful.
- Emmy's pattern in early relationships was seeking intense, high-effort partners (including one who shut down Versailles for a second date), but these relationships burned out when she prioritized her career.
- At twenty-one, Emmy married Justin impulsively after he presented it as either marry-or-break-up before she left for six months of filming, later recognizing she had planned the divorce before even getting married.
- Emmy spent nearly a decade single and searching before meeting her husband Sam, whose letter about being a filmmaker with therapy debt and anxiety initially impressed her more than his physical appearance.
- Emmy did not say 'I love you' back when Sam first confessed his feelings a week before they started filming together, but she changed her mind after seeing him work on set and later told him she felt the same way.
- Emmy experienced severe postpartum anxiety with intrusive thoughts after her daughter's birth, compounded by her family history of death in childbirth, despite the joy of finally having a child after PCOS and IVF struggles.
- During IVF, Emmy became a 'super responder' and produced 72 eggs, then developed hyperstimulation syndrome that required fluid extraction into an empty Diet Coke bottle, illustrating how medical procedures for fertility can be unexpectedly primitive.
- Emmy's mother never bought herself new underwear and funneled all resources into Emmy's private school education, teaching her survival and capability but not emotional expression, which Emmy has forgiven as her mother's own trauma response.
- Watching her husband be an extraordinarily devoted father to their daughters has been the 'ultimate healing' for Emmy's abandonment wounds from her absent father, allowing her to experience the stable male presence she never had.
Topics
Transcript
Call Her Daddy is brought to you by Silk. If you're trying to get more protein into your routine, I know I am, especially in the morning, you already know it's not always easy to find something that actually fits your lifestyle and also actually tastes good. That is where Silk Protein comes in. Silk just launched a new plant-based protein milk designed to help you start your day strong and something delicious, convenient, and easy to work into your routine. Silk Protein delivers 13 grams of complete plant protein per serving, along with three grams of fiber and 50% less sugar than dairy milk. It's made to help support your morning routine and help you stay on track, whether…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Call Her Daddy
How to Heal Your Trust Issues
Alexandra Cooper discusses how a formative relationship with a manipulative, unfaithful boyfriend created deep trust issues that followed her through subsequent relationships, and how she eventually healed those issues through therapy, self-awareness, and a partner (Matt) who consistently demonstrated trustworthiness and emotional safety.
Sonja & Luann: Pirates, Palm Beach & Picking Up Men
Sonja Morgan and Luann de Lesseps discuss their return to reality television with 'The Golden Life,' a new show featuring OG Real Housewives of New York cast members. They reflect on their decades-long friendship, dating experiences in their 60s, and how they've evolved as women and entrepreneurs since their original Housewives run.
Unreliable Boyfriends & Unexpected Proposals
Alex Cooper hosts a Call Her Daddy Sunday session where she answers listener questions about relationships, including topics like friendship betrayals, unreliable partners, flirting boundaries, long-distance visits, aggressive behavior, sexual compatibility, and unexpected proposals. She shares personal anecdotes from her college days and provides candid relationship advice based on her experiences.
Tinashe: Broke Boys, Golf Bros & Short Kings
Tinashe discusses her journey from a 14-year-old girl group member to an independent artist, navigating industry pressures while maintaining authenticity. She shares insights on dating standards, relationship patterns, and her new album 'Pop Star,' emphasizing the importance of not conforming to industry expectations and prioritizing personal fulfillment over external validation.
Holly & Bridget: Controlling Men 101 (FBF)
Holly Madison and Bridget Marquardt discuss their experiences living at the Playboy Mansion for seven years, exploring themes of control, objectification, coercion into sexual situations, beauty standards, eating disorders, and their paths to healing and independence after leaving the mansion.