OpinionStory

I decided to try music grading

Boston Card Hunter

The speaker attempts music grading for the first time, specifically grading their favorite grunge album. They discuss the debate around grading sealed CDs, compare it to comic book grading practices, and explain why they're comfortable with a sealed copy since they listen to music via Spotify and vinyl instead.

Summary

The speaker decides to try music grading as a new activity and selects their all-time favorite grunge album as the subject. They acknowledge an interesting debate within the grading community: some people question the value of grading sealed music because it cannot be played in a CD player, while others draw parallels to the long-established practice of grading comic books, where sealed copies are intentionally kept unopened. The speaker shares their personal perspective, noting that they appreciate the sealed condition and the hype sticker on the album. They justify their comfort with keeping the CD sealed by explaining that they don't plan to play it anyway, preferring instead to listen to music through alternative formats like Spotify streaming or vinyl records. The speaker assigns a grade of seven to the album but expresses uncertainty about whether grading standards for music are strict and whether factors like "pop count" (likely referring to manufacturing defects) are considered in the grading process. They conclude by calling the grading experience cool and inviting audience feedback on whether music grading is a worthwhile pursuit.

Key Insights

  • The speaker received pushback from some who question the value of grading sealed CDs since they cannot be played in a CD player
  • Comic book grading has established a decades-long precedent for sealing and grading collectibles that cannot be accessed in their original form
  • The speaker appreciates the sealed condition with hype sticker because they never intended to play the physical CD anyway
  • The speaker grades their album a seven but acknowledges uncertainty about whether music grading standards are strict or whether specific defects like 'pop count' factor into the grade
  • The speaker's primary music consumption methods are Spotify and vinyl rather than CD players, which supports their willingness to keep the CD sealed

Topics

Music grading as a hobbyValue debate of grading sealed CDsComparison to comic book grading practicesSealed album preservationMusic consumption formats (streaming, vinyl, CD)

Transcript

[0:00] I decided to give music grading a shot. This is my all-time favorite grunge album. And it's kind of an interesting debate. I hear people on one side say they don't really think this has any value because I can't open this up and play it and put it in a CD player. And yet other people are like, "Well, they've been doing that with comic books for decades, right? Where you seal up the comic book, you can only see the front and the back of it." Me personally, I like the fact that this thing's sealed with a hype sticker. And I was never going to play this anyway. I'll play it on Spotify or vinyl. I…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Boston Card Hunter

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.