Trump assassination attempt conspiracies explained | Top Comment
The hosts analyze conspiracy theories surrounding a Trump assassination attempt at the White House Correspondents' Dinner, examining coordinated MAGA messaging about a Trump ballroom, left-wing 'Blue Anon' staging theories, and the broader trend of politically motivated violence being gamified through social media by both suspects and witnesses.
Summary
The video opens with mockery of UFC CEO Dana White's bravado response to the assassination attempt, where he boasted about refusing to get down despite Secret Service orders, calling it 'awesome.' The hosts find this behavior cringe-worthy and use it to set the tone for a broader media criticism discussion.
A major focus is the suspiciously fast and unified messaging from MAGA influencer accounts about Trump needing a private White House ballroom, which began circulating almost immediately after the shooting. The hosts note that Trump himself was on C-SPAN pushing the ballroom narrative by 10:30 PM, less than 90 minutes after the shooting began. Former conservative influencer Ashley Sinclair allegedly revealed the existence of a group chat called 'Fight Fight Fight' connecting MAGA influencers with administration members, suggesting coordinated messaging. The hosts acknowledge this coordination is hard to prove definitively but argue the statistical likelihood of independent convergence on the same ballroom talking point is extremely low.
The discussion then shifts to what the hosts call 'Blue Anon' — a left-wing mirror of QAnon — where anti-Trump accounts, including prominent figures like Joyce Carol Oates, have consistently claimed Trump's assassination attempts (Butler, the golf course, and the Correspondents' Dinner) are staged. The hosts note that each failed attempt is used as further 'evidence' of staging, and that these accounts use the same conspiratorial logic they previously condemned in Trump supporters. Caroline Levitt's pre-dinner comment about 'shots being fired' was clipped and framed as foreknowledge, which the hosts dismiss as absurd.
The hosts critique social media 'sleuth culture,' highlighting a viral tweet analyzing a photo of the suspect using medical terminology like 'supratrochlear vein,' likely used incorrectly, from an account with 'crypto entrepreneur' in their bio. They argue this kind of pseudo-expertise spreads rapidly and contributes to genuine public confusion about what is real.
The discussion touches on the suspect's manifesto, which appeared to outline rules of engagement including exempting Kash Patel — possibly because the suspect anticipated his removal from the administration. This detail itself became fuel for conspiracy theories. The hosts also note a new selfie taken by the suspect in the hotel room before the shooting, adding to the digital trail.
The hosts then examine a disturbing broader trend: the 'genZification' of political assassination, where suspects like Cole Allen and Thomas Matthew Crooks seem to deliberately curate a digital footprint, leaving clues, taking selfies, and trolling online. Both suspects were described as relatively politically centrist, complicating partisan narratives about ideological motivation.
Finally, the episode critiques the influencification of journalism, pointing to a MAGA influencer at the Correspondents' Dinner who posted a pout selfie falsely claiming the shooter was dead, and then issued a casual correction. The hosts argue this exemplifies the problem with granting influencers the same access as credentialed journalists.
Key Insights
- The hosts argue that MAGA influencer accounts posted in near-unison about Trump's ballroom project within minutes of the shooting, and that former conservative influencer Ashley Sinclair revealed a group chat called 'Fight Fight Fight' connecting these accounts to administration members, suggesting coordinated messaging.
- The hosts identify a 'Blue Anon' phenomenon — left-wing accounts mirroring QAnon-style reasoning — where prominent figures like Joyce Carol Oates consistently claim Trump's assassination attempts are staged, using each failed attempt as further evidence of a conspiracy.
- The hosts observe that suspects like Cole Allen and Thomas Matthew Crooks appear to deliberately curate their digital footprints — taking selfies, leaving manifesto clues, and trolling online — suggesting a 'genZification of assassination' driven more by desire for online reaction than clear political ideology.
- The hosts argue that Tucker Carlson and Joe Kent's claims that Butler shooting investigations were shut down, combined with Candace Owens attributing it to an Israeli-American donor, represent a slide of Butler conspiracy theories into antisemitic territory even within MAGA circles.
- A MAGA influencer at the Correspondents' Dinner posted a glamour selfie falsely declaring the shooter dead, then casually corrected it by saying 'breaking news is always the first draft of history,' which the hosts use to argue that granting influencers press access creates serious misinformation risks.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Dana White, the CEO of UFC and longtime Trump ally. This was so cringe. He He was interviewed afterwards and he was like, they told him to get down. I didn't get down. >> They were screaming, "Get down." I didn't get down. It was awesome. I literally took every minute of it in. >> It's like, "Okay, tough guy." Like, "You didn't get down when like the Secret Service was telling you to get down cuz an active shooter." It reminded me of those joke videos about like not giving a girl the ick when the plane is crashing, you know? Like trying to like make it really cool, make yourself look [0:31] really cool. Like so you…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from BBC News
'One if not the largest strikes by Russia on Kyiv since war began'. #Ukraine #Russia #BBCNews
Russia launched one of its largest aerial assaults on Kyiv since the start of the war, involving hundreds of drones and dozens of missiles. While most were intercepted, several struck civilian areas including a metro station, shopping center, and residential block. The attack signals that President Putin remains committed to continuing the war.
At least 82 killed in Chinese coal mine explosion. #China #BBCNews
A gas explosion at the Liucheng New Mine in Shanxi, China killed at least 82 workers and hospitalized over 100, making it the worst mining accident in the country in over a decade. Rescue robots are being deployed to reach potentially trapped survivors in toxic tunnels. The incident raises questions about mine safety despite years of stricter regulations.
DR Congo reports more than 200 Ebola deaths | BBC News
The Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo has killed 204 people across three provinces with 867 suspected cases, marking the worst African outbreak in a decade. The Africa CDC has warned 10 countries are at risk, prompting regional surveillance efforts. Response efforts are severely hampered by the M23 rebel conflict in eastern Congo, which has restricted access to affected territories.
Spirit Airlines shutting down after rescue talks collapse | BBC News
Spirit Airlines has ceased operations after failing to secure government bailout funding, becoming the first major US airline casualty in 25 years. The collapse is largely attributed to the Iran war, which has caused jet fuel prices to nearly double, creating unsustainable cost pressures. Aviation consultant Paul Charles warns that other smaller carriers may face similar fates in the coming days.
Is this the true face of Anne Boleyn? | BBC News
A BBC News segment investigates whether facial recognition technology can identify a true portrait of Anne Boleyn, wife of Henry VIII. A University of Bradford team applied facial recognition to historical sketches, proposing that the traditionally accepted portrait may actually depict her mother. Art historians remain deeply skeptical of the methodology.