How is the Iran war fuelling false claims about “cloud stealing”? #Iraq #Iran #US #BBCNews
An Iraqi MP claimed US aircraft were stealing clouds to cause drought in the Middle East, a claim debunked by Iraq's own meteorological authority. While cloud seeding is a real weather modification technique, it cannot create clouds from nothing or move them across borders. Climate change, not cloud theft, is the real driver of worsening weather extremes in the region.
Summary
The video addresses a viral misinformation claim made by an Iraqi MP who alleged that US aircraft were deliberately stealing clouds from the Middle East to cause drought. Iraq's own meteorological authority dismissed the claim as neither scientific nor logical.
The claim emerged against a backdrop of genuine drought conditions affecting several Middle Eastern countries, including Iraq, Turkey, and Iran. When rain eventually fell in the region, some social media users claimed without evidence that the US had stopped deploying weather weapons — further spreading the conspiracy theory.
The video contextualizes these claims within a longer history of conspiracy theories around weather modification. Cloud seeding, a legitimate scientific technique, has long fueled such theories. Cloud seeding works by manipulating existing clouds to increase precipitation by up to 15%, but it cannot create clouds from scratch, nor can it move clouds across national borders — directly contradicting the MP's claims.
The video concludes by pointing to climate change as the actual cause of worsening weather in the Middle East. Temperatures in the region are rising twice as fast as the global average, heat waves are growing longer and more intense, and while overall rainfall is decreasing, precipitation increasingly arrives in short, intense bursts. The segment firmly concludes that no one is stealing clouds.
Key Insights
- An Iraqi MP claimed US aircraft were stealing clouds in the Middle East to deliberately cause drought, a claim Iraq's own meteorological authority described as neither scientific nor logical.
- When rain returned to the region after a drought period, some social media users claimed without evidence that the US had stopped using weather weapons, framing natural rainfall as proof of prior interference.
- Cloud seeding, a real weather modification technique, can increase precipitation from existing clouds by up to 15%, but scientists confirm it cannot create clouds from nothing or move them across borders.
- Temperatures in the Middle East are rising twice as fast as the global average due to climate change, making heat waves longer and more intense while reducing overall rainfall frequency.
- While overall rainfall in the Middle East is decreasing, climate change is causing precipitation to arrive in short, intense bursts rather than being distributed evenly — a pattern distinct from any alleged weather manipulation.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access