Kenner Star Wars Price Guide | "Potpourri Edition"
The Action Figure Grader reviews recent eBay sales of vintage Kenner Star Wars collectibles, covering loose figures, graded items, and mint-on-card pieces. The episode culminates in a warning about a seller whose mint-on-card listings appear to use double-sided tape and reproduced or altered card backs to fake authenticity, with multiple buyers potentially having been defrauded.
Summary
The host, known as the Action Figure Grader, opens the episode by previewing two main segments: a review of recent eBay sales for vintage Kenner Star Wars items, and an investigation into suspicious mint-on-card listings flagged by a viewer.
The sales review begins with lower-ticket items. A First 12 display stand with mailer box sold for $255, which the host describes as one of the cheapest he's seen for that item. An early bird certificate with display stand and paperwork sold for $776 ungraded, contrasted against a CAS 75 graded example that previously sold for over $2,000. An AFA 80 early bird mailer kit with a non-telescoping Luke Skywalker sold for $7,500, which the host describes as toward the lower end of the range for that grade.
The host then covers double-telescoping saber figures: an ungraded example in rough condition sold for $728, while an AFA 80 telescoping saber Luke farm boy sold for $1,250 through an affiliate link sent to his Patreon members. A holo cheeks Tusken Raider in near-mint condition sold for $350, which the host notes has come down from around $450 and is now a consistent market price.
Several graded vehicle and accessory sales are covered: a CAS 90 diecast Slave I sold for $330, an AFA 85 laser rifle carry case sold for $637, and a CAS 80 Plus Chewbacca with Power of the Force coin sold for $243. The host highlights the rarity of finding an AT-ST driver in high grade, noting this AFA U85 example sold for $262 and almost never appears at auction.
Further graded figure sales include an AFA 90 Hong Kong COO blue saber Luke Skywalker for $635, an AFA 80 R2-D2 pop-up lightsaber for $829 (versus a UKG 90% that sold for over $1,500), a JSA-certified John Ratzenberger autographed Hoth Rebel Commander UKG 85 for $271, an AFA 85 Plus blank raised bar COO Luke Bespin for $678, an AFA 90 Mon Mothma baggy for $510, an AFA 85 loose Mon Mothma for $455, an AFA 85 Imperial Gunner for $510, and an AFA 80 Plus Yak Face for $740.
The episode's most significant segment involves a seller whose mint-on-card listings raised serious authenticity concerns. The host initially featured the Power Droid listing in a 'what to buy' video, noting it looked suspicious but was reassured by an old Kmart price sticker. However, a viewer on Instagram sent photos revealing that the blisters appear to be held on with double-sided tape rather than original heat seals, suggesting either repro blisters or repro card backs dressed up with vintage stickers. The Ben Kenobi listing most clearly shows the tape and a visible divot near the white racetrack area. A Children's Palace sticker was also used on another card. Despite the seller updating their auction to disclose a buyer's concerns, the host suggests a seller with the username 'Jedi Master Demetri' should have recognized these signs. The Power Droid still sold for $766, the Ben Kenobi for $810, a Leia for $571, and a Death Squad Commander 12-back for $457. The host urges viewers who purchased these items to return them and recommends sticking with trusted sellers and AFA-graded examples when possible.
The episode closes with a few legitimate sales: a 12-back A Tusken Raider for $910, a transition 48-back Lando with yellowed blister for $382, and a tri-logo Logray with immaculate blister for $305.
Key Insights
- The host argues that an AFA 80 early bird mailer kit with non-telescoping Luke Skywalker selling for $7,500 is actually toward the lower end of the price range for that grade, suggesting the market for this item regularly exceeds that figure.
- The host observes that the AT-ST driver is extremely difficult to find in high grade, attributing this partly to collector indifference and partly to the figure's torso yellowing easily, making this AFA U85 example the first he had seen at auction in the new case style.
- The host explains that AFA 90 grades for baggies are nearly impossible to achieve because even minor lettering rub will drop the grade to an 85 or lower, making the Mon Mothma AFA 90 baggy selling for $510 a strong deal given a loose AFA 85 sold for $455 in the same auction.
- The host describes how a fraudulent seller used double-sided tape to reattach blisters to card backs — either repro blisters or repro cards dressed with vintage price stickers like Kmart and Children's Palace stickers — to fake authentic mint-on-card status, and the Ben Kenobi listing most clearly exposed this with visible tape and a divot near the white racetrack border.
- The host states that the holo cheeks Tusken Raider market has softened, with near-mint ungraded examples now consistently selling around $350, down from approximately $450 previously.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access